FEDERAL DISTRICT ARCHIVE
Central District of California
Press releases recorded for this federal judicial district.
Two California Men Arrested for Email Hacking Scheme That Yielded Nude Photos That Were Posted on 'Revenge Porn' WebsiteRead the Press Release
LOS ANGELES – The FBI arrested two men this morning for allegedly conspiring to hack into victims’ e-mail accounts to steal nude photos that were later posted on the “revenge porn” website isanyoneup.com.
Hunter Moore, 27, of Woodland, who operated isanyoneup.com, and Charles Evens, 25, of Studio City, were arrested without incident by special agents with the FBI. Both men are expected to make initial court appearances this afternoon – Moore in federal court in Sacramento, and Evens in United States District Court in Los Angeles.
Moore and Evens are charged in a 15-count indictment unsealed after they were arrested this morning. The indictment charges both men with conspiracy, seven counts of unauthorized access to a protected computer to obtain information and seven counts of aggravated identity theft.
According to the indictment, Moore operated the website http://isanyoneup.com, where he posted, among other things, nude or sexually explicit photos of victims. The pictures were submitted without the victim’s permission for purposes of revenge. However, to obtain more photos to populate the site, Moore allegedly instructed Evens to gain unauthorized access to – in other words, to hack into – victims’ e-mail accounts. Moore sent payments to Evens in exchange for nude photos obtained unlawfully from the victims’ accounts. Moore then posted the illegally obtained photos on his website, without the victims’ consent. The indictment alleges that Evens hacked into email accounts belonging to hundreds of victims.
An indictment contains allegations that a defendant has committed a crime. Every defendant is presumed to be innocent until and unless proven guilty in court.
If convicted, Moore and Evens face up to five years in federal prison for each of the conspiracy and computer hacking counts. The charge of aggravated identity theft carries a mandatory two-year sentence to run consecutive to any other sentence imposed in the case.
The investigation that led to this morning’s arrest of Moore and Evens was conducted by the Federal Bureau of Investigation.Release No. 14-008
Denver Man Who Promoted Credit Services Scheme to Fraudulently Obtain Business Lines of Credit Sentenced to Federal PrisonRead the Press Release
LOS ANGELES – A Denver man who billed himself as “The Credit Line Millionaire” was sentenced today to 21 months in federal prison as a result of his role in a scheme to obtain lines of credit worth hundreds of thousands of dollars through a host of misrepresentations and falsified documents.
Christopher Robert Wise, 35, was sentenced today by United States District Court Judge John Kronstadt in Los Angeles. Wise has been in federal custody since his arrest by the United States Secret Service at Los Angeles International Airport last August after he arrived on a flight from Mexico.
Wise pled guilty in October to conspiracy to commit bank fraud, admitting that he conspired to fraudulently obtain lines of credit from Wells Fargo Bank, Union Bank and City National Bank.
According to prosecutors, Wise maintained a significant online presence, which included his websites www.creditlinemillionaire.com and http://chriswise.com/, and he billed himself as a credit guru who could help clients obtain loans for their small- and medium-size businesses. Wise referred his clients to several co-conspirators who controlled Inland Empire companies and who promised to help acquire financing.
As part of his guilty plea, Wise admitted attempting to obtain business lines of credit for himself through loan applications submitted to the victim banks on behalf of one of his companies. Wise also admitted he used a co-conspirator as a “credit partner” to pose as a “personal guarantor” for the loans – in essence, using a “straw borrower” to apply for loans in exchange for giving the credit partner a percentage of the loan proceeds.
At sentencing, prosecutors relied on an online video of defendant speaking at one of his seminars where he summarized his scam, saying, among other things:
“My credit is messed up. I’m getting over a million dollars. I have leveraged over a million dollars in the past. I’m getting ready to get another million dollars in one shot . . . My business doesn’t qualify for the revenue documentation, because as a business owner I like to write everything off. Right, that is one of the advantages of being a business owner. And so when you go to the bank and you show them everything is written off, they don’t really like to see that. So my business doesn’t qualify. And so by leveraging other people’s credit and by leveraging other people’s entities, I’m now in the process of getting a million dollars line of credit.”
Previously in this investigation, five co-conspirators pleaded guilty, four of whom are pending sentencing. Last month, Avedis Abraham Hagopian was sentenced to two years in federal prison for his role in the scheme.
This case is the result of an investigation by the United States Secret Service.
Release No. 14-009
Three Men Charged in Federal Court for Starting Illegal Campfire in Angeles National Forest That Became Colby FireRead the Press Release
LOS ANGELES, California – Three men were charged this afternoon in United States District Court with illegally setting a campfire above Glendora that erupted in Santa Ana winds last week to become a destructive wildfire called the Colby Fire.
Federal prosecutors filed a criminal complaint that charges the three men with unlawfully setting timber afire, a felony offense that carries a possible five-year prison term.The three men named in the criminal complaint are:
Clifford Eugene Henry Jr, 22, of Glendora;
Steven Robert Aguirre, 21, a transient; and
Jonathan Carl Jarrell, 24, also a transient.
The three men were taken into custody by local officials last Thursday after the fire started. Henry, Aguirre and Jarrell are expected to be turned over to federal authorities this afternoon. The defendants are expected to make their first appearance in federal court tomorrow, possibly as early as 11:00 a.m.
The Colby Fire started on the morning of January 16. By that evening, the fire had consumed more than 1,700 acres of federal, state, local and private lands. The fire had also destroyed five residences, damaged 17 additional structures, and resulted in injuries to one civilian and two firefighters.
Henry, Aguirre and Jarrell were detained by Glendora Police Officers after they were seen escaping the fire. During interviews with Glendora Police and personnel with the Los Angeles County Fire Department’s Arson Investigations Unit, all three defendants admitted playing a role in the starting of a campfire that started the Colby Fire after wind blew burning paper into the brush in the hills above Glendora, according to the affidavit in support of the criminal complaint.
A United States Forest Service fire investigator has determined that the origin of the Colby Fire was at a point near a fire ring built by Henry, Aguirre and Jarrell; the cause of the fire was embers from the campfire that set dry grass adjacent to the campfire ring afire; and both the campfire ring and the origin of the fire are clearly located on federal lands within the Angeles National Forest.
The investigation is being conducted by the United States Forest Service, the Glendora Police Department and the Los Angeles County Fire Department.
Release No. 14-007
San Fernando Valley Pastor Arrested for Running A Fraudulent Investment Scheme That Targeted Spanish-Speaking InvestorsRead the Press Release
LOS ANGELES – A Chatsworth man was arrested this morning by the U.S. Postal Inspection Service and the Federal Bureau of Investigation after being named in a federal grand jury indictment that charges him with running a multi-million dollar Ponzi scheme that targeted Latino victims.
Luis Alonso Serna, 61, who operated Architects of the Future Investments, which he purported to be a foreign currency investment company, was arrested this morning on federal charges that allege he ran a Ponzi scheme that lured more than 70 victims into investing almost $4 million.
“The Ponzi scheme is a century-old concept, but it remains a clear and present danger to the investing public,” said United States Attorney André Birotte Jr. “Cases like the one against Mr. Serna demonstrate the accuracy of the old adage that if it sounds too good to be true, it almost certainly is.”
Serna, the pastor of Zion Living Word Christian Center (formerly Amistad Cristiana) in San Fernando, was named in a superseding indictment returned on January 10. The indictment charges him with two counts of mail fraud, two counts of wire fraud and two counts of money laundering. Serna is expected to be arraigned on the indictment this afternoon in United States District Court in Los Angeles.
“The Postal Inspection Service has no shortage of Ponzi schemes to investigate, and this is another sad example of greed overcoming honest business practices,” said B. Bernard Ferguson, Inspector in Charge for the Los Angeles Division. “Relying on a reputation or relationship is not enough -- investors must still verify information, especially if there are claims of outperforming the market.”
According to the indictment, Serna claimed to be a successful investor, but he in fact operated a Ponzi scheme by soliciting funds from investors with false claims that their money would be used to purchase foreign currency. Serna allegedly promised to pay the victims monthly returns of up 20 percent. Serna and people working with him sometimes convinced victims to take liens on their homes to invest, according to prosecutors, who noted that many of those victims lost their homes and some declared bankruptcy.
Bill Lewis, the Assistant Director in Charge of the FBI’s Los Angeles Field Office, said: “The FBI is committed to pursuing criminals who prey upon the investing public through various methods, including sophisticated affinity-fraud schemes such as the one we're announcing today. Justice for the victims in this case can be attributed to the collaborative efforts of federal law enforcement.”
An indictment contains allegations that a defendant has committed a crime. Every defendant is presumed to be innocent until proven guilty in court.
If he is convicted, Serna would face a statutory maximum penalty of 20 years in federal prison for each of the four fraud charges and up to 10 years in prison for both of the money laundering counts.
This case was investigated by the United States Postal Inspection Service and the Federal Bureau of Investigation.
Release No. 14-005
Man Who Conspired with Female Friend to Solicit ‘Hit Man’ to Kill Her Daughter’s Boyfriend Sentenced to 7 Years in Federal PrisonRead the Press Release
SANTA ANA, California – A Hawthorne man who pleaded guilty in a murder-for-hire scheme targeting a man who was dating the daughter of his co-conspirator was sentenced today to seven years in federal prison.
Antonio Quevedo, 35, was sentenced by United States District Judge Josephine L. Staton.
The second defendant in the case – Adelina Cristobal, 56, of Lawndale, who also pleaded guilty last year to conspiracy to use interstate commerce facilities in the commission of murder-for-hire – is scheduled to be sentenced by Judge Staton on January 31.
The murder-for-hire scheme was uncovered during an investigation by the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives (ATF) and the Los Angeles Police Department. Investigators initiated the investigation after receiving information that the two defendants were attempting to solicit someone to commit a murder on their behalf. An undercover officer posing as the hired “hit man” met with the defendants, who offered the undercover officer $6,500 to kill the intended victim. Cristobal was to pay Quevedo an additional $500 for arranging the meeting with the “hit man.”
Quevedo conspired with Cristobal to hire someone to murder the boyfriend of Cristobal’s daughter, prosecutors wrote in a sentencing memorandum that noted “Had the government not been able to infiltrate the conspiracy, [Quevedo] may well have found a willing assassin to murder the victim and successfully collected his broker’s fee.”
Release No. 14-006
Los Angeles-Area Gang Member Pleads Guilty to Sex Trafficking of Minors by ForceRead the Press Release
Lynwood Man Becomes Eighth Convicted of Sex Trafficking Charges for Prostituting Teenage Girls Recruited from Inland Empire Schools
Conviction is the Latest in a String of Human Trafficking Prosecutions
Recently Brought by the United States Attorney’s OfficeRIVERSIDE, California – On the day a jury was expected to hear opening statements in his trial, a Lynwood gang member pleaded guilty on Tuesday to federal sex trafficking charges, admitting that he used force, fraud and coercion to recruit teen-age girls who worked as prostitutes across Southern California.
Paul Edward Bell, 29, an alleged member of the Rolling 60s Crips street gang, pleaded guilty on Monday pursuant to a plea agreement that calls for a sentence of 30 years in federal prison.
Bell, who used multiple monikers, including J-Roc, pleaded guilty before United States District Judge Virginia A. Phillips, who is scheduled to determine whether to accept the 30 year binding plea agreement and sentence the defendant to that term of imprisonment on March 31, 2014.
Bell is the eighth and final defendant convicted after a federal grand jury returned an indictment in August 2012 that resulted from an investigation by the Inland Child Exploitation/Prostitution Task Force, which is comprised of agents, deputies and officers with the Federal Bureau of Investigation, the Riverside County Sheriff’s Department, the Riverside Police Department, the San Bernardino Police Department, the Pomona Police Department, and the Ontario Police Department.
In court documents previously filed in this case, prosecutors said that Bell and his co-defendants used minors as prostitutes for their own financial gain. They preyed on vulnerable victims, convinced them to become prostitutes, and verbally and physically abused them when they did not perform as required, according to various court documents.
In a plea agreement filed yesterday, Bell specifically admitted that in 2011 he recruited and harbored four minor victims (ages 15 to 17) that he forced to work as prostitutes in Lynwood and Compton. Bell admitted physically abusing one victim “for not performing as a prostitute and for acting up,” according to the plea agreement.
“Sex trafficking is an abominable crime that condemns its victims to physical and psychological trauma, hardship and abuse,” said United States Attorney André Birotte Jr. "Mr. Bell and his cohorts coldly and brutally victimized young women and juveniles, subjecting them to treatment that can only be described as inhumane. Bell exploited his victims for profit and now he will be held accountable and punished for his predatory conduct."
“The defendants in this case lured minor victims from school with false promises of a glamorous lifestyle only to sexually exploit and abuse them in furtherance of the gang, and for their own financial gain,” said Bill Lewis, the Assistant Director of the FBI’s Los Angeles Field Office. “January is Human Trafficking Awareness Month and today’s announcement should send a message to those with similar intentions of targeting minors that the FBI and our task force partners are committed to investigating allegations of sex trafficking and sending them to prison.”
The other defendants in this case who previously pleaded guilty are:
Samuel Rogers, also known as Bone, 23, of Moreno Valley, another alleged member of the Rolling 60s, who pleaded guilty to sex trafficking of a minor;
Gary Rogers, who used monikers such as G-Man, 25, of Moreno Valley, another alleged member of the street gang and Samuel Rogers’ brother, who pleaded guilty to conspiracy to engage in sex trafficking; Christopher Weldon, who is also known by several names, including C-Roc, 24, of Compton, the fourth alleged Rolling 60s member named in the indictment and Bell’s half-brother, who pleaded guilty to one count of conspiracy to engage in sex trafficking and received a six-year prison sentence;
Javiya Brooks, who is also known as Shady Blue, 21, of Lynwood, who was the lead prostitute for Bell, who pleaded guilty to one count of conspiracy to engage in sex trafficking;
Kimberly Alberti, 20, of Riverside, who was the lead prostitute for Samuel Rogers, who pleaded guilty to one count of conspiracy to engage in sex trafficking;
Kristy Harrell, 21, of Riverside, who was Gary Rogers’ lead prostitute, who pleaded guilty to interstate transportation in the aid of racketeering; and
Su Yan, 31, of Rosemead, a Chinese national who assisted Bell with his prostitution business and pleaded guilty to interstate transportation in the aid of racketeering.
The defendants who have not been sentenced will also be sentenced later this year by Judge Phillips.
The investigation in this case began in January of 2011, when the Riverside County Sheriff’s Department learned that teenage girls attending schools in the Inland Empire were being recruited to work as prostitutes. The investigation later revealed that Alberti attended one of the schools and recruited underage females by “grooming them” -- or gaining their trust and telling them that they could make large sums of money by working as prostitutes for Alberti's pimp. The girls who were successfully recruited to work as prostitutes were brought to the Los Angeles area, where they were housed by Bell and the Rogers brothers at hotels on and near Long Beach Boulevard or at Bell's apartment.
The United States Attorney’s Office worked with the Justice Department’s Child Exploitation and Obscenity Section to prosecute this case.
The case being announced today was brought as part of Project Safe Childhood, a nationwide initiative to combat the growing epidemic of child sexual exploitation and abuse launched in May 2006 by the Department of Justice. Led by United States Attorneys’ Offices and the Criminal Division's Child Exploitation and Obscenity Section (CEOS), Project Safe Childhood marshals federal, state and local resources to better locate, apprehend and prosecute individuals who exploit children via the Internet, as well as to identify and rescue victims. For more information about Project Safe Childhood, please visit www.projectsafechildhood.gov.
Fighting human trafficking has been, and will remain, a priority for the Central District of California. The convictions announced today are the latest in a string of human trafficking cases that the United States Attorney’s Office, working in partnership with federal and local law enforcement, has brought in the past year. Over the past year, the United States Attorney’s Office has also prosecuted the following matters, among others:
United States v. Letha Montemayor Tucker, CR No. 13-78-ABC. On March 12, 2013, a federal grand jury returned a first superseding indictment charging Letha Montemayor Tucker with conspiracy to produce child pornography, production of child pornography, conspiracy to engage in sex trafficking of a child, and sex trafficking of a child. Tucker was arrested last year after tips from members of the public to the U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement’s Homeland Security Investigation agency helped identify her as a woman allegedly seen molesting a pre-teen victim in a series of child photography images that had been widely-distributed over the Internet. The jury trial in this case is set for April 8, 2014. Tucker faces a mandatory minimum sentence of 15 years and a statutory maximum of life imprisonment if convicted.
United States v. Roshaun Nakia Porter and Marquis Monte Horn, CR No. 12-97(A)-JLS. On March 27, 2013, a federal grand jury returned a first superseding indictment charging Roshaun Nakia Porter and Marquis Monte Horn with conspiring to engage in sex trafficking and sex trafficking by force, fraud, and coercion. According to court documents filed in this case, Horn allegedly recruited victims to work in a prostitution organization through a website and by claiming that he and Porter were running an upscale escort service in which women could make $500 per day. Prosecutors allege that this was merely a ruse; and that Horn, Porter, and others used various coercive tactics -- including developing purportedly romantic relationships with the victims, falsely promising financial assistance to the victims and their families, falsely promising to help obtain lawful immigration status in the United States for their victims, and isolating some of the victims from their families and friends -- all to induce these victims into engaging in prostitution. Both Horn and Porter face a mandatory minimum sentence of 15 years and a statutory maximum of life imprisonment if convicted. Their trial is set for February 18, 2014.
United States v. William Earl Flavors, CR No. 13-143-JLS. On August 7, 2013, a federal grand jury returned an indictment charging William Earl Flavors, aka “Andre,” with sex trafficking by force, fraud, or coercion, and transportation in interstate commerce for purposes of prostitution. On December 5, 2013, Flavors pleaded guilty to transportation in interstate commerce for purposes of prostitution, admitting, among other things, that he transported his victims between Long Beach to Las Vegas, forced or coerced them to work as prostitutes in Las Vegas, and used physical abuse and threats of additional physical abuse to make one of his victims work for him as a prostitute. Flavors’ conviction in this case marks the second time Flavors has been convicted in federal court of trafficking women across state lines and forcing them to work as prostitutes. Pursuant to the parties’ plea agreement, Flavors and the government agreed to recommend the statutory maximum sentence of 10 years’ imprisonment. Sentencing is set for May 9, 2014.
United States v. Joshua Jerome Davis & Sharilyn Kae Anderson, CR No. 13-589-CAS. On August 22, 2013, a federal grand jury returned an indictment charging Joshua Jerome Davis with sex trafficking of a child, coercion and enticement to travel in interstate commerce to engage in prostitution, and transportation of a child for purposes of prostitution. As detailed in the criminal complaint filed in this case, Davis is accused of prostituting a 16-year-old girl in Southern California and transporting her across state lines to engage in commercial sex in Las Vegas casinos. The Department of Homeland Security and the Long Beach Police Department began investigating this case after the victim’s father reported her missing and discovered that his daughter was being featured in an on-line prostitution ad. The indictment also charged Davis’ mother, Sharilyn Kae Anderson, with aiding and abetting the child sex trafficking offenses committed by her son. A jury trial in this case is set for April 22, 2014. Both defendants face a mandatory minimum sentence of 15 years and a statutory maximum of life imprisonment if convicted.
United States v. Tabitha Samaria Walls and Kenyati Jakeen Rahh-Potts, CR No. 13-637-MWF. On September 4, 2013, a federal grand jury returned an indictment charging Tabitha Samaria Walls and Kenyati Jakeen Rahh-Potts with sex trafficking of a child and transportation of a minor for purposes of prostitution. According to the criminal complaint filed in this matter, Walls and Rahh-Potts allegedly forced the child victim in this case to accompany them from Las Vegas to California, where they forced her to engage in acts of prostitution in Los Angeles, Hollywood, Pomona, and Ontario. It is further alleged in the criminal complaint that the child victim was forced to surrender all of the money that she earned as a prostitute to Walls and Rahh-Potts, that Rahh-Potts beat her on one occasion when she lost the money she earned as a prostitute, and that Rahh-Potts told two individuals who attempted to rescue the child victim from Walls and Rahh-Potts that he had killed the child victim and left her body on the side of the road along the Interstate 15 freeway. The trial in this case is scheduled for June 17, 2014. Both Walls and Rahh-Potts face a mandatory minimum sentence of 15 years and a statutory maximum of life imprisonment if convicted.
United States v. Curtis Maurice Canady, Jr., CR No. 13-165-DOC. On September 4, 2013, a federal grand jury returned an indictment charging Curtis Maurice Canady Jr. with sex trafficking of children and transportation of children for purposes of prostitution. Canady pleaded guilty on November 19, 2013, to transportation of children for purposes of prostitution. As detailed in court documents filed in this case, Canady drove his victims, including two girls who were 15 and 16, from a motel in Los Angeles to locations in Anaheim where he had them work as prostitutes; transported his victims, including a minor victim, to Las Vegas for the purpose of engaging in prostitution; and engaged in on-line advertising aimed at attracting customers for his victims. At sentencing, Canady faces a statutory maximum sentence of life imprisonment.
United States v. Vincent Earl Jordan, 13-657(A)-BRO. On October 29, 2013, a federal grand jury returned a first superseding indictment charging Vincent Earl Jordan, aka “Vinnie Mac,” with sex trafficking of a minor, sexual exploitation of a child, possession of child pornography, transportation of a child for purposes of prostitution, and coercion and enticement to travel in interstate commerce to engage in prostitution. As detailed in court documents filed in this matter, this case began when Long Beach Police Department detectives encountered a 17-year-old girl engaged in acts of prostitution who had a moniker, “Vinnie,” tattooed across her stomach. The documents allege that, after this child victim identified Jordan as her pimp, the police found a second victim who also alleged that Jordan had threatened and coerced her to travel from Texas to California to work as a prostitute. The indictment further alleges that Jordan produced and possessed child pornography of his 17-year-old victim. The jury trial in this case is set for February 25, 2014. Jordan faces a statutory minimum sentence of 15 years and a statutory maximum of life imprisonment if convicted.
United States v. Samuel Gonzalez, CR No.11-193-AG. On November 15, 2013, Samuel Gonzalez pleaded guilty pursuant to a plea agreement to arranging and facilitating travel of minors for prostitution. As detailed in court documents filed in this case, Gonzalez lured three teenage girls from Texas to California under the guise that he wanted to take them “to the beach.” Once in California, Gonzalez induced these minor victims to work as prostitutes, until the family of one of the teenage victims reported the victims missing and Gonzalez was apprehended. As a result of this guilty plea, Gonzalez faces a maximum sentence of 30 years’ imprisonment. Sentencing is set for February 24, 2014.
United States v. Eric Lamar Wells and Tonisha Alecia Moore, CR No. 12-120-CJC. On May 23, 2012, a federal grand jury returned an indictment charging Eric Lamar Wells and Tonisha Alecia Moore with conspiracy to engage in sex trafficking of minors, sex trafficking of minors, and transportation of minors into prostitution. As detailed in court documents filed in this case, Wells recruited a 14-year-old girl and a 17-year-old girl to work as prostitutes for him. Wells and Moore then transported these girls from Las Vegas, Nevada, to Phoenix, California, and finally to Anaheim, California, so that they could engage in commercial sex acts and give the money they made to Wells. Wells also posted on-line ads to find men who would pay to engage in sex acts with the minor victims. Following their guilty pleas, on June 26, 2013, the court sentenced Wells to 10 years’ imprisonment and Moore to 70 months’ imprisonment.
United States v. Kawaum Marquez Scott and Nekeyia Necole Weatherspoon, CR No. 13-116-VAP. On November 27, 2013, a federal grand jury returned an indictment charging defendants Kawaum Marquez Scott and Nekeyia Necole Weatherspoon with conspiracy to engage in sex trafficking of a child and sex trafficking of a child. Jury trial is set for April 29, 2014. In the criminal complaint filed in this case, it is alleged that Scott and Weatherspoon befriended a 14-year-old victim who lived at a residence located on the same property where Scott and Weatherspoon lived; forced this 14-year-old victim to engage in prostitution, pocketing for themselves all of the money this victim made; and utilized the Internet to advertise this child victim as a prostitute. Defendants face a statutory minimum sentence of 15 years and a statutory maximum of life imprisonment if convicted.
United States v. Ralph Allen Jackson, Jr., CR No. 13-476(A)-BRO. On December 16, 2013, Ralph Allen Jackson, Jr., 41, also known as “Mac Wimp,” pleaded guilty to conspiracy to engage in sex trafficking of a minor. In his plea agreement, Jackson admitted that he trafficked four victims – including a 17-year-old girl – in the Long Beach area in June 2013. As detailed in court documents filed in this matter, Jackson drove his victims to known areas for prostitution, instructed them to engage in sex acts for money, gave them quotas that they were required to meet each day, and engaged in acts of coercion to insure that his victims continued to work for him as prostitutes. When law enforcement first encountered the minor victim in this case, she was branded with the words “Mac Wimp’s bitch” tattooed across her chest. Pursuant to the terms of the plea agreement, Jackson has agreed to recommend that he serve a sentence of no less than five years’ imprisonment, and the government agreed to recommend a sentence of no more than ten years’ imprisonment. Sentencing is set for March 10, 2014.
An indictment or complaint contains allegations that a defendant has committed a crime. Every defendant is presumed innocent until and unless proven guilty in court.
January 2014 has been proclaimed National Slavery and Human Trafficking Prevention Month by President Obama (see: http://www.whitehouse.gov/the-press-office/2013/12/31/presidential-proclamation-national-slavery-and-human-trafficking-prevent). In addition to efforts to investigate and prosecute human trafficking violations, law enforcement has also been proactive with respect to outreach, education and prevention efforts in local communities. To that end, on Saturday, January 11, the United States Attorney’s Office for the Central District of California and the Los Angeles Field Office of the FBI co-hosted an Anti-Human Trafficking Summit to assist local prevention efforts and help raise awareness about the many facets of human trafficking. The all-day Summit was held at the National Council of Jewish Woman/Los Angeles (NCJWLA) in Los Angeles and featured presenters and participants from federal and local law enforcement, as well as local community stakeholders and victims’ services organizations. Presenters included prosecutors, investigators, subject matter experts, victims’ advocates and victims who were survivors of human trafficking. United States Attorney André Birotte Jr. and FBI Assistant Director in Charge Bill Lewis also participated. Volunteers from the Expediente Rojo Project, Inc. (http://www.expedienterojo.org/) and NCJWLA assisted in all facets of the Summit.
Release No. 14-004
El Salvadoran National Sentenced to 15 Years in Federal Prison in Credit Card Fraud CaseRead the Press Release
LOS ANGELES – An El Salvadoran national who was convicted of credit card fraud, trafficking in counterfeit goods and identity theft has been sentenced to 15 years in federal prison for causing victims to suffer losses of over $100,000.
Jose Rolando Renderos, 39, who last resided in Montebello, but has been in federal custody since February 1, 2013, was sentenced yesterday afternoon by United States District Judge Audrey B. Collins. In October 2013, a federal jury convicted Renderos of various federal charges related to a credit card manufacturing scheme.
Renderos was apprehended on February 1, 2013, after receiving a box of more than 3,000 counterfeit credit cards imported from China and then leading law enforcement on a high-speed chase through the San Gabriel Valley. All told, authorities seized more than 100,000 counterfeit credit cards and numbers in packages imported from China and at a credit card manufacturing plant that Renderos had operated in Montebello, California.
“Credit card fraud and identity theft impact the financial security, privacy, and emotional well-being of millions of Americans every year,” said United States Attorney André Birotte Jr. “Mr. Renderos is a repeat offender who callously disregarded the effect that his schemes had on the lives of his unfortunate victims and now he will be serving a lengthy and richly deserved sentence in federal prison.”
“Identity theft and credit card fraud are growing at an alarming rate, posing a real threat to consumers and financial institutions nationwide,” said Claude Arnold, special agent in charge for HSI Los Angeles. “As this sentencing shows, those who perpetrate such schemes face serious consequences. HSI will continue to work closely with its federal law enforcement partners to aggressively target those who seek to undermine the integrity of our financial system and compromise our quality of life.”
At trial, federal prosecutors presented evidence that Renderos had lived a luxurious lifestyle that had been financed by credit card fraud. The ill-gotten gains paid for cosmetic surgery for himself and his girlfriend, VIP tickets to Lakers and Clippers games, and designer handbags and shoes.
“Our success in this case and other similar investigations is a result of our close work with our law enforcement partners,” said Joseph Beaty, Special Agent in Charge of the U.S. Secret Service Los Angeles Field Office. “The Secret Service worked closely with the U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement’s Homeland Security Investigations to share information and resources that ultimately brought Jose Rolando Renderos to justice.”
During the investigation, authorities learned that Renderos obtained valid credit card numbers by installing “skimmers” inside gas station pumps throughout Southern California. Renderos used others to block cameras and distract gas station employees while he did the installation. Six other defendants were also prosecuted as part of the scheme, including his girlfriend, his 18 year-old son, his brother, and others who purchased products for Renderos using the counterfeit credit cards.
Renderos was previously convicted of credit card fraud in the California courts. When he was arrested last year, Renderos was a fugitive wanted by federal authorities after he absconded from supervised release imposed after he was convicted of interstate transportation of a stolen vehicle. Renderos was also wanted by local authorities because he absconded while being prosecuted in Los Angeles County on credit card fraud charges. While a fugitive, Renderos had assumed the identities of several Puerto Rican men to hide from authorities.
The case was investigated by the U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement’s Homeland Security Investigations and the United States Secret Service with substantial assistance provided by U.S Customs and Border Protection.
Release No. 14-003
San Fernando Valley Woman Pleads Guilty to Federal Charges in $25 Million Health Care Fraud CaseRead the Press Release
LOS ANGELES -- A North Hollywood woman who worked in the health care industry pleaded guilty today to federal charges for orchestrating a scheme that submitted nearly $25 million in fraudulent bills to Medicare for services and supplies, including power wheelchairs and diagnostic tests that were medically unnecessary and sometimes were never provided.
Susanna Artsruni, 46, who formerly owned a durable medical equipment (DME) company and worked at a number of medical clinics in Los Angeles, pleaded guilty this afternoon before United States District Judge Margaret M. Morrow. Artsruni, who often used the names “Mary” and “Rose,” pleaded guilty to one count of health care fraud and one count of money laundering.
In a plea agreement filed last year in United States District Court, Artsruni admitted that she defrauded Medicare in a number of ways. In one part of the scheme, Artsruni had physician’s assistants at three Los Angeles medical clinics sign prescriptions and orders for medically unnecessary DME and diagnostic tests that were later referred to other Medicare providers that billed for the equipment and tests. Artsruni also caused the three clinics to bill Medicare for medically unnecessary services. Further, Artsruni fraudulently billed Medicare on behalf of her own DME supply company, Midvalley Medical Supply in Van Nuys, for medically unnecessary DME based on referrals from one of the three medical clinics.
In total, Artsruni caused more than $24.8 million in fraudulent claims to be submitted to Medicare, which paid more than $9.2 million on the bogus bills.
Artsruni also admitted that she wrote checks totaling more than $35,000 from the Midvalley bank account to three corporations that had no connection to the medical industry and apparently had not provided any legitimate business services to Midvalley. Artrsuni admitted that she wrote these checks to conceal the nature of the funds as the proceeds of health care fraud and used the three corporations to launder these funds.
At the time that she worked at two of the clinics and wrote one of the checks to launder the proceeds of her fraud, Artsruni was free on bond in another health care fraud case (United States v. Artsruni, CR08-209-CAS). Although the terms of her pre-trial release in the 2008 case dictated that she not commit crimes and forbid her from working at medical facilities, Artsruni concealed her activities from her Pre-Trial Services Officer and engaged in the fraudulent conduct that led to most of the losses suffered by Medicare in the second case.
As a result of today's guilty pleas, Artsruni faces a statutory maximum sentence of 30 years in federal prison. Judge Morrow is scheduled to sentence Artsruni on April 14.
A second defendant in the case, Erasmus Kotey, a physician's assistant who worked with Artsruni in a medical clinic on North Vermont Avenue in Los Angeles, is scheduled to go on trial before Judge Morrow on April 8.
The case against Artsruni and Kotey is the product of an investigation by the Federal Bureau of Investigation; the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Office of Inspector General; and IRS - Criminal Investigation.
Release No. 14-002
Santa Barbara Doctor Known as ‘Candy Man’ Pleads Guilty to Illegally Writing Prescriptions for Huge Quantities of Dangerous NarcoticsRead the Press Release
SANTA ANA, California – A Santa Barbara physician was remanded into custody this morning after he pleaded guilty to 11 federal drug trafficking charges for writing prescriptions for powerful painkillers for “patients” who were drug addicts.
Julio Gabriel Diaz, 65, who operated the Family Medical Clinic in Santa Barbara prior to his arrest two years ago, pleaded guilty to 10 counts of distributing controlled substances without a legitimate medical purpose and one count of distributing controlled substances to a minor (which, under federal law, is a person under 21).
Diaz pleaded guilty before United States District Judge Cormac J. Carney, who is scheduled to sentence the defendant on June 2. Diaz, who will be held in jail until his sentencing, faces a maximum statutory sentence of 200 years in federal prison and fines of up to $10 million.
“Dr. Diaz was, quite simply, acting as a common drug dealer,” said United States Attorney André Birotte Jr. “The diversion of powerful painkillers from legitimate medical uses to the hands of drug abusers is a dangerous practice that fuels addiction and causes overdoses. Far too many of the illegal prescription drugs that find their way to street users come from doctors who, like Julio Diaz, choose to betray their Hippocratic oath.”
In a plea agreement filed last year in United States District Court, Diaz admitted distributing narcotics such as oxycodone, methadone, hydrocodone, alprazolam, fentanyl and hydromorphone in 2009 and 2010. Diaz admitted that he distributed or dispensed the narcotics “while acting and intending to act outside the usual course of professional practice and without a legitimate medical purpose.”
Court documents previously filed in this case, as well as civil lawsuits, link Diaz to fatal drug overdoses. However, he was not specifically charged with causing any deaths, nor did he specifically admit causing any deaths during today’s hearing.
The investigation into Diaz was conducted by the Drug Enforcement Administration and the Santa Barbara Police Department, which received the assistance of the California Medical Board.
Release No. 14-001
Southern California Man Pleads Guilty to Attempting to Assist Al-Qai'da by Providing Weapons Training to Fighters in PakistanRead the Press Release
LOS ANGELES -- An Orange County man pleaded guilty this morning to a federal terrorism offense, admitting that he intended to assist al-Qai'da by traveling to Pakistan, where he would provide weapons training to members of the terrorist group.
Sinh Vinh Ngo Nguyen, 24, of Garden Grove, California, pleaded guilty this morning to one count of attempting to provide material support to a designated foreign terrorist organization.
Nguyen, who also used the name Hasan Abu Omar Ghannoum, pleaded guilty this morning before United States District Judge John F. Walter, who is scheduled to sentence the defendant on March 21. At the time of sentencing, Nguyen faces a statutory maximum penalty of 15 years in federal prison.
In a plea agreement filed last Friday in United States District Court, Nguyen admitted that approximately one year ago he travelled to Syria where he joined opposition forces. Using a social network site during a four-month period he was in Syria, Nguyen told people that he was fighting against the Assad regime and that he had had a "confirmed kill." After he returned to the United States, Nguyen told associates that he had offered to train al-Qai'da forces in Syria, but his offer had been turned down.
Between August 3 and October 11, Nguyen met with a man he thought was an al-Qai'da recruiter, but who in fact was working with the FBI. Within the first few minutes of their first meetings, Nguyen began questioning the man to determine if he was a fellow jihadist, according to the plea agreement. Nguyen told the man about his exploits in Syria and said he wanted to return to jihad because "this was what he was born to do."
During their meetings, Nguyen and the man he thought was an al-Qai'da recruiter discussed how Nguyen could travel to Pakistan under a fraudulently obtained United States passport. After Nguyen gave the purported recruiter a photo of himself and a passport application with bogus information, Nguyen agreed to travel to Pakistan, where he would train 30 al-Qai'da fighters for 5 or 6 weeks to prepare them "for a guerilla warfare ambush attack on coalition forces" that would take place this month, according to the plea agreement.
With the intention to travel to Pakistan to train al-Qai'da forces for the ambush, Nguyen on October 1 purchased a plane ticket to travel from Mexico to Peshawar, Pakistan, he admitted in the plea agreement. On October 11, Nguyen went to a bus station in Santa Ana where he purchased a ticket to Mexico. On this date he was arrested by FBI agents. When he was taken into custody, Nguyen had in his possession the false passport and a computer hard drive that contained "over 180 training videos on shooting firearms."
Nguyen has been in federal custody since his arrest.
The case against Nguyen is the product of an investigation by the Federal Bureau of Investigation.
Release No. 13-152
Jury Finds Pueblo Bishop Gang Member Guilty in RICO Murder Case for Ambush Killing of Father in Front of His 2-Year-Old SonRead the Press Release
LOS ANGELES -- A member of the Pueblo Bishop Bloods street gang was convicted by a federal jury today for the murder of a young man with no gang affiliation who was executed in front of his 2-year-old son.
Rondale Young, also known as “P-Grump,” 30, of South Los Angeles, was convicted on several counts after a two-week jury trial before United States District Judge S. James Otero. Young was found guilty of violating the federal Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations Act (RICO) in relation to the murder of 23-year-old Francisco Cornelio.
In addition to the RICO offense, Young was convicted of witness intimidation related to Young’s conduct after he was arrested for the murder. The jury also found Young guilty of conspiring to murder Mr. Cornelio, as well as the actual murder, both of which were done in furtherance of the Pueblo Bishop criminal enterprise. In addition, Young was convicted of using a gun that resulted in murder. Based on these convictions, Young faces a mandatory minimum term of life in federal prisonment, plus ten years.
Young is scheduled to be sentenced by Judge Otero on May 26.
The federal convictions come after Young had been acquitted in Los Angeles Superior Court on murder charges related to the slaying of Mr. Cornelio. After the acquittal in state court, the FBI’s Los Angeles Metropolitan Task Force on Violent Gangs re-investigated the case and uncovered additional evidence related to the murder and Young’s involvement with the Pueblo Bishops.
The evidence presented at trial showed that Young drove his car, which contained other armed gang members, into rival gang territory early on the morning of August 2, 2009. The Pueblo Bishops were seeking retaliation after an earlier shooting against their gang. The Pueblo Bishops targeted Mr. Cornelio because he appeared to be Hispanic and was in rival gang territory. According to witnesses who testified, two Pueblo Bishops, who were armed with shotguns, got out of Young’s vehicle and ambushed an unsuspecting Mr. Cornelio, who was washing his car. The gang members shot him once in the back without saying a word, while the victim’s son sat in the back seat of the car. There was no evidence that Cornelio had any gang ties.
The murder was unsolved prior to a federal racketeering indictment that was unsealed in August 2010. http://www.justice.gov/archive/usao/cac/Pressroom/pr2010/122.html). The federal indictment charged that Young and his co-defendants were members of a criminal enterprise that engaged in murder, drug dealing, firearms trafficking, witness intimidation and armed robbery as part of the gang’s efforts to control and terrorize the Pueblo Del Rio Housing Projects in South Los Angeles.
Young is the third person to be convicted in federal court in relation to the murder of Mr. Cornelio. In a prior trial, a federal jury determined that Anthony “Bandit” Gabrourel was also part of the plot by Pueblo Bishop members to murder Mr. Cornelio. At that trial, the evidence showed that Gabourel was one of two Pueblo Bishops who exited Young’s car with shotguns and fatally shot Mr. Cornelio. Gabrourel was sentenced earlier this year by Judge Otero to 40 years in federal prison. The third person conviction in relation to the murder was sentenced to five years in prison for hiding the murder weapon after the slaying.
As a result of the federal investigation into the racketeering activity of the Pueblo Bishop Bloods, a total of 45 defendants were charged in federal indictments. Prosecutors have secured convictions against 41 of those defendants. Two defendants are in state custody after receiving lengthy sentences for violent gang crimes, and two are fugitives.
The investigation into the Pueblo Bishop Bloods was conducted by the Federal Bureau of Investigation; the Los Angeles Police Department, Newton Division; the United States Department of Housing and Urban Development, Office of Inspector General; and the Los Angeles County District Attorney’s Office.
Release No. 13-151
Seven High Desert Residents Arrested by Members of Federal-State Task Force for Allegedly Selling MethamphetamineRead the Press Release
RIVERSIDE, California – An investigation by the High Desert Gang Impact Team this morning resulted in the arrest of seven defendants who face charges in federal and state court for distributing methamphetamine in the High Desert region.
The arrests this morning mark the culmination of a two-year investigation by the High Desert Gang Impact Team, which is made up of agents and deputies with the Federal Bureau of Investigation and the San Bernardino County Sheriff’s Department. Task Force members are continuing to search for two defendants who face federal charges.
A federal grand jury on November 27th returned five indictments in United States District Court that charge a total of six defendants. The federal indictments charge these defendants with distributing, and conspiring to distribute, methamphetamine.
The federal defendants, three of whom are expected to be arraigned this afternoon in United States District Court in Riverside, are:
- Christian Alejandro Navarro, 29, of Hesperia;
- Aldo Serna-Avila, 28, of Apple Valley;
- Johnnie Zuniga, 37, of Apple Valley;
- Candelario Vasquez, 49, of Apple Valley; who is in state custody on an unrelated charge;
- Jessica Enriquez, 29, of Apple Valley, who is currently a fugitive; and
- Virginia Gomez, 46, of Apple Valley, who is also being sought by authorities.
The federal defendants arrested today are expected to make their initial court appearances this afternoon in the United States District Court in Riverside. The six federal defendants, if convicted, each face a five-year mandatory minimum sentence and a statutory maximum sentence of 40 years.
Three defendants were charged by the San Bernardino County District Attorney’s Office with state narcotics offenses. The three defendants facing state charges are:
- Sally Oporto, 35, of Apple Valley;
- Nelly Rodriguez, 76, of Apple Valley; and
- Lucia Martinez, 46, of Victorville.
An indictment or complaint contains allegations that a defendant has committed a crime. Every defendant is presumed innocent until and unless proven guilty in court.
FBI agents with the Victorville resident agency; sheriff’s deputies from the Victorville, Apple Valley, Hesperia, and Adelanto sheriff’s stations; and officers from the San Bernardino County Probation Department participated in the execution of arrest warrants this morning.
Release No. 13-150
Westside Man Arrested on Money Laundering Charges Related to Alleged Embezzlement of Nearly $370,000 from Girl ScoutsRead the Press Release
LOS ANGELES – A Marina Del Rey man is expected to make his first court appearance this afternoon after being arrested yesterday by FBI agents on federal charges of laundering $50,000 out of approximately $370,000 he allegedly embezzled from the Girl Scouts.
Channing Smack, 51, who was a senior property manager of the Girl Scouts of Greater Los Angeles (GSGLA), was arrested yesterday without incident. Smack is named in a criminal complaint that was also filed late yesterday charging him with money laundering, a federal offense that carries a maximum sentence of 10 years in federal prison.
Smack was arrested after being interviewed by FBI agents about the alleged embezzlement and one day after he withdrew $64,500 from accounts believed to contain proceeds of the scheme.
According to the affidavit in support of the complaint, Smack was responsible for managing the GSGLA’s 22 properties in the Los Angeles area. Over the past year and a half, Smack approved invoices for services purportedly provided by a firm called ZB Land Maintenance & Engineering, which is registered under the name of Smack’s deceased brother. Between August 2012 and October 2013, allegedly at Smack’s direction, GSGLA issued 23 checks to ZB that totaled $368,278. The evidence uncovered by the FBI shows that most of the checks to ZB were then deposited into one of two bank accounts opened under the names of the company and Smack’s deceased brother. According to the affidavit, bank surveillance photographs show an individual who looks like Smack either depositing or withdrawing funds into or from these bank accounts.
This past Monday, federal prosecutors served federal seizure warrants on three bank accounts believed to contain embezzled funds – the ZB account and two personal accounts in Smack’s name into which he is believed to have transferred funds derived from the GSGLA checks.
A criminal complaint contains allegations that a defendant has committed a crime. Every defendant is presumed to be innocent until proven guilty in court.
The criminal complaint against Smack is the product of an ongoing investigation by the Federal Bureau of Investigation.
Release No. 13-148
Bay Area Woman Guilty in Investment Scam That Caused over $9 Million in LossesRead the Press Release
SANTA ANA, California -- A San Jose woman was convicted today of a federal fraud charge for running a Ponzi scheme that bilked more than 250 victims out of approximately $9.5 million.
Bich Quyen Nguyen, 59, was found guilty conspiring to commit wire fraud, a crime that carries a possible penalty of 20 years in federal prison.
Nguyen was found guilty by a jury before United States District Judge Josephine L. Staton, who remanded Nguyen into custody after the jury’s verdict was returned. Judge Staton is scheduled to sentence Nguyen on March 13.
The evidence presented during a six-day trial showed that Nguyen told victims that she was the chief executive officer of a Swedish credit union that offered guaranteed returns as high as 46.2 percent on one-year certificates of deposit involving at least $1 million. Nguyen told victims that she used “trading platforms” and made trades at a high frequency and velocity to achieve the high rates of return. Nguyen told victims that their investments were safe because the victims’ money would be in “blocked” accounts. Nguyen told victims that she had prepared for the 2008 financial crisis so their returns were still protected and guaranteed.
To get the rates that Nguyen fraudulently promised, victims from southern California and Nevada organized private investment clubs to pool the required $1 million. Several of the victim investment clubs were located in Anaheim and Rialto. During the second half of 2008, Nguyen and co-conspirators made presentations to victims across the region, with some of the presentations taking place at churches.
In the Spring of 2009, the Securities and Exchange Commission obtained orders from United States District Judge David O. Carter that prevented Nguyen and her co-conspirators from continuing to offer these investments. Following the issuance of the injunctions, a receiver and forensic accountant reviewed records and determined that the victims’ money was never “safe,” in part because it was commingled with other victims’ money; some of the victims’ money was used to make Ponzi payments to other investors; and the promised investments were never made. Despite Judge Carter’s orders, Nguyen in May and July 2009 continued to offer investments in Las Vegas and overseas.
Previously in this case, another member of the conspiracy – Johnny Edward Johnson, 70, a former Bay Area resident who was arrested earlier this year while traveling in Central America – pleaded guilty to conspiracy to commit wire fraud. Johnson, who also faces a statutory maximum sentence of 20 years in federal prison, is scheduled to be sentenced by Judge Staton on March 28.
The investigation of Nguyen and Johnson was conducted by the Federal Bureau of Investigation. The SEC provided substantial assistance.
Release No. 13-149
Federal Grand Jury Charges San Fernando Valley Man with First-Degree Murder in Fatal Shooting of TSA Officer at LAXRead the Press Release
LOS ANGELES – A federal grand jury this afternoon returned an 11-count indictment that charges Paul Anthony Ciancia with first-degree murder in the fatal shooting of a Transportation Security Administration Officer during a shooting spree at Los Angeles International Airport last month.
Ciancia is charged with murdering Gerardo Hernandez, an officer and employee of the United States, while Officer Hernandez was engaged in his official duties on November 1.
The indictment also charges Ciancia with attempted murder for shooting TSA Officers Tony Leroy Grigsby and James Maurice Speer. The indictment alleges that Ciancia used a Smith & Wesson 5.56-millimeter M&P15 semiautomatic rifle to shoot the three TSA Officers.
Ciancia, 23, who at the time of the shooting resided in Sun Valley, also is charged with using the rifle to commit acts of violence against persons at an international airport, including Brian Donovan Ludmer, a civilian who was wounded during the rampage.
The indictment contains one count alleging that Ciancia knowingly used a firearm to murder and cause death, and three counts alleging that he did “knowingly carry, brandish, discharge and use a firearm” when he shot the three surviving victims.
The indictment is a charging document that replaces the criminal complaint filed soon after the shooting incident. The indictment was filed this afternoon in United States District Court after the grand jury determined that there was “probable cause” to find that Ciancia committed the 11 felony offenses. Ciancia is scheduled to be arraigned on the indictment on December 26.
The three charges based on the killing of Officer Hernandez – first-degree murder, violence at an international airport that resulted in death, and using a firearm to murder and cause death – each carry possible sentences of life in federal prison or the death penalty. The indictment contains a series of allegations that would support a possible sentence of death, including premeditation and the murder of a federal law enforcement officer. At this time, the government has not made a decision on seeking the death penalty if Ciancia is convicted of any of these charges.
The two attempted-murder charges and each of the three charges based on violence against the surviving victims all carry a statutory maximum penalty of 20 years in federal prison. The three counts alleging the use of a firearm each carry a mandatory minimum sentence of 10 years that would be served consecutively to any other sentences that are imposed.
An indictment contains allegations that a defendant has committed a crime. Every defendant is presumed to be innocent until proven guilty in court.This case is the product of an investigation by members of the Los Angeles Joint Terrorism Task Force (JTTF), which is led by the Federal Bureau of Investigation and includes agents and officers from 45 other local, state and federal agencies.
The following agencies provided considerable assistance during the investigation: the Los Angeles World Airports Police Department; the Los Angeles Police Department; the Los Angeles County Sheriff's Department; the Transportation Security Administration; the Federal Air Marshal Service; the Los Angeles Port Police; the Long Beach Police Department; the Air Force Office of Special Investigations; the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives; U.S. Customs and Border Protection; the United States Secret Service; the Los Angeles Fire Department; Los Angeles International Airport Operations; the United States Marshals Service; the United States Postal Inspection Service; the Ronald Reagan UCLA Medical Center; and U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement’s Homeland Security Investigations.
Release No. 13-147
Former Chief Administrative Officer for City of Bell Agrees to Plead Guilty to Conspiracy and Tax Charges in Plot to Avoid Income TaxesRead the Press Release
LOS ANGELES -- Robert A. Rizzo, who for years was the top administrator in the City of Bell and who became a symbol of municipal corruption, has agreed to plead guilty to federal charges in a scheme that resulted in hundreds of thousands of dollars in unpaid federal income tax.
In a plea agreement filed today in United States District Court, the 59-year-old Rizzo agreed to plead guilty to two felony charges: conspiracy and filing a false federal income tax return with the Internal Revenue Service. In the plea agreement, the Torrance resident admitted that he created a corporation to fraudulently claim losses on his income tax return, which served to illegally reduce his tax liability on the significant income he was receiving from the City of Bell.
According to the plea agreement and the information, which is the charging document in the case and was also filed this morning, Rizzo, sometime in 2002, created an S Corporation that he called R.A. Rizzo Incorporated (RARI). Rizzo was assisted in the scheme by co-conspirators that included his tax preparer, Robert J. Melcher, who has pleaded guilty to aiding and abetting the filing of a false tax return.
Rizzo used RARI to claim bogus losses in relation to a purported rental property in Auburn, Washington. RARI’s corporate tax return fraudulently deducted more than $409,731 in losses for the years 2006 through 2009.
Rizzo also admitted in his plea agreement that he used a RARI account to pay for more than $80,000 in personal expenses in 2009 and $120,000 in construction work on his residence in Huntington Beach in 2010. RARI’s tax returns falsely claimed that these expenses were related to rental property.
“It is regrettable that some public officials believe they are above the law,” said Richard Weber, Chief, IRS Criminal Investigation. “Instead of filing accurate tax returns, Mr. Rizzo claimed bogus corporate losses on his income tax return to illegally reduce his tax liability. Pursuing public servants who corruptly endeavor to circumvent the tax laws to fund their lavish lifestyles is a top priority for IRS Criminal Investigation.”
As part of his plea agreement Rizzo agreed to file amended individual and S Corporation tax returns for the years 2006 through 2010 that will correctly report all income and expenses. He also agreed to pay all additional taxes and penalties, including the 75 percent fraud penalty.
As a result of their actions, Rizzo and his co-conspirators caused the IRS to suffer losses of more than $300,000 for the 2006 through 2010 years.
Rizzo will be summoned to appear in federal court for an arraignment in this case. Once he pleads guilty to the two felony charges, Rizzo will face a maximum statutory sentence of eight years in federal prison.
Melcher, who as a result of his guilty plea faces a sentence of up to three years in prison, is scheduled to be sentenced next year by United States District Judge George H. King.
The cases against Rizzo and Melcher are part of an ongoing investigation being conducted by special agents with IRS Criminal Investigation and the Federal Bureau of Investigation.
Release No. 13-145a
Doctor Pleads Guilty to Tax Offense Related to Health Care Fraud Scheme Involving People Recruited from ‘Skid Row’Read the Press Release
LOS ANGELES – In the first case filed in relation to the second major investigation into the illegal recruitment of “Skid Row” denizens for unnecessary medical procedures, a La Mirada doctor pleaded guilty this afternoon to federal tax charges and admitted participating in a large-scale scheme to defraud Medicare and Medi-Cal.
Dr. Ovid Mercene, 61, of La Mirada, pled guilty today to subscribing to a false tax return. Mercene pleaded guilty before United States District Judge R. Gary Klausner, who is scheduled to sentence the defendant on July 21.
From 2008 and 2012, while Mercene worked at a Los Angeles-area hospital, he admitted patients, the vast majority of whom were homeless, who had been referred from a purported “care consortium.” The patients, many of whom did not require hospitalization, were admitted for the purpose of defrauding taxpayer-funded health programs such as Medicare, Mercene admitted in court today.
Mercene admitted the “patients” after watching them being transported by van from Skid Row to the hospital, where they were often kept on a special floor away from the hospital’s “regular” patients. These “patients” also were given smoking breaks while in the hospital, even though many of them supposedly suffered from respiratory diseases. After a short hospital stay where numerous unnecessary tests were typically performed, Mercene discharged the “patients” to skilled nursing facilities, even though they did not require such care.
Mercene billed Medicare and Medi-Cal more than $1.8 million for medically unnecessary services provided to the Skid Row patients while in the hospital or at a skilled nursing facility.
Mercene received nearly $700,000 in cash kickbacks for admitting “patients” to skilled nursing facilities -- income he did not report on his tax returns.
The case against Mercene is part of an ongoing investigation into the recruitment of Skid Row patients being conducted by the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Office of Inspector General; the Federal Bureau of Investigation; IRS-Criminal Investigation; and the California Department of Justice’s Bureau of Medi-Cal Fraud and Elder Abuse.
Release No. 13-145
Former San Luis Obispo Police Officer Sentenced to 18 Months in Federal Prison in Corruption CaseRead the Press Release
LOS ANGELES -- A former detective with the San Luis Obispo Police Department has been sentenced to 18 months in federal prison for extorting sources he cultivated while working on a narcotics task force.
Cory Pierce, 40, of Arroyo Grande, was sentenced Monday afternoon by United States District Judge Margaret M. Morrow. In addition to the prison term, Judge Morrow sentenced Pierce to three years of supervised release and ordered him to pay $5,500 in restitution. Pierce was ordered to begin serving his sentence by January 27.
Pierce, who served with the San Luis Obispo Police Department for six years, pleaded guilty in June to a federal extortion charge. When he pleaded guilty, Pierce admitted that while assigned to a narcotics task force, he cultivated as sources an individual who had been arrested for heroin possession, and the man's girlfriend. Pierce obtained painkillers from the sources in exchange for providing them with placebo oxycodone pills that they could sell.
As part of the plea agreement, Pierce admitted to using his position as a police officer to obtain $11,000 from someone who he thought was a drug dealer in exchange for the placebo pills.
The investigation was conducted by the Federal Bureau of Investigation.
Release No. 13-144
Orange County Criminal Defense Attorney Sentenced to A Year in Prison in Federal Bribery CaseRead the Press Release
SANTA ANA, CALIFORNIA – An Orange County criminal defense attorney, who was convicted by a jury of executing a bribery scheme to obtain dismissal of a state criminal case against one of his clients, was sentenced today to 12 months and one day in federal prison.
Lawrence Anthony Witsoe, age 70, a resident of Mission Viejo, CA, was sentenced by United States District Judge Andrew J. Guilford. In September, Witsoe’s co-defendant, Aaron Scott Vigil, who was a police officer with the Rialto Police Department and a Task Force Officer with the U.S. Drug Enforcement Administration (“DEA”), was sentenced to 33 months in prison for his role in the bribery scheme.
In addition to his prison sentence, Witsoe’s license to practice law was suspended on August 12, 2013 as a result of his conviction in this case, according to State Bar records.
Earlier this year, a federal jury convicted both Witsoe and Vigil of conspiring to solicit a $2,500 bribe from one of Witsoe’s clients, who was charged with assault in a state criminal case, in exchange for having Officer Vigil falsely represent to the Orange County District Attorney’s Office that Witsoe’s client had been cooperating with Officer Vigil and the DEA in connection with drug investigations. In addition to the conspiracy count, Witsoe was also found guilty of two other counts, namely, soliciting the bribe payment from his client and offering and giving the bribe payment to Officer Vigil.
Release No. 13-143a
Glendale Man Who Admitted Hacking into Hundreds of Computers in ‘Sextortion’ Case Sentenced to Five Years in Federal PrisonRead the Press Release
LOS ANGELES – A Glendale man who hacked into hundreds of online accounts and victims’ computers, using extortion to coerce women into showing their naked bodies, was sentenced today to 60 months in federal prison.
Karen “Gary” Kazaryan, 27, was sentenced by United States District Judge George H. King, who said the defendant was a “cyber-terrorist.” Judge King remanded Kazaryan into custody at the conclusion of the sentencing hearing.
Kazaryan pleaded guilty in July to felony counts of computer hacking and aggravated identity theft.
In sentencing papers that recommended a six-year prison term, prosecutors wrote: “Kazaryan is a sexual cyber terrorist. He hacked into hundreds of victims’ email, Facebook, and Skype accounts using their usernames and passwords or password reset questions. He then methodically searched their accounts for naked pictures, passwords, and the contact information of their friends. He had two goals every time that he accessed these accounts: get more naked pictures in any way he could, and get more victims.”
According to court documents, Kazaryan gained unauthorized access to – meaning he hacked into – online accounts. In some cases, he obtained naked pictures from those accounts and then extorted the victims to provide additional photos and videos. If they refused, he posted the original pictures on the Internet. In other cases, Kazaryan posed as young women and asked their friends to provide naked photos.
“His victims were devastated and felt like they had been raped,” according to the sentencing memorandum. “They continue to be thoroughly traumatized by his criminal conduct.”
The investigation was conducted by the Federal Bureau of Investigation.
“Sextortion” is a type of extortion or blackmail of a victim who is usually asked for a nude image. The perpetrator typically threatens to publicly release a nude image unless a victim performs a sexual act or complies with other demands. To avoid become a victim, everyone should be prudent when posting images online or to any wireless communication (computer, phone, tablet), especially if the images have private or compromising content. Victims who receive extortionate threats or whose personal accounts have been compromised are urged to contact a parent, trusted adult or law enforcement, since the situation will only worsen. As always, computer users are warned to ensure their passwords are difficult for others to guess, avoid opening unverified attachments, and use reliable anti-virus software with updated definitions. Lastly, computer users should cover their webcam when it’s not in use.
Release No. 13-142
18 Charged as Result of Federal Investigation into Corruption and Civil Rights Abuses by Members of L.A. County Sheriff’s DepartmentRead the Press Release
Current and Former Deputies Charged with Federal Crimes, including Illegal Beatings of Jail Inmates and Obstruction of Justice
LOS ANGELES – Five criminal cases that charge a total of 18 current or one-time deputy sheriffs of various ranks were unsealed today as part of ongoing and wide-ranging FBI investigation into allegations of civil rights violations and corruption involving members of the Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Department. Four grand jury indictments and one criminal complaint allege crimes that include unjustified beatings of jail inmates and visitors at downtown Los Angeles jail facilities, unjustified detentions and a conspiracy to obstruct a federal investigation into misconduct at the Men’s Central Jail.
Federal authorities announced the charges after 16 of the defendants were taken into custody earlier today. Those defendants are expected to be arraigned on the charges this afternoon in United States District Court in Los Angeles.
“The five cases allege a wide scope of illegal conduct,” said United States Attorney André Birotte Jr. “This investigation started by focusing on misconduct in county jails, and we uncovered examples of civil rights violations that included excessive force and unlawful arrests.
“Our investigation also found that these incidents did not take place in a vacuum – in fact, they demonstrated behavior that had become institutionalized. The pattern of activity alleged in the obstruction of justice case shows how some members of the Sheriff’s Department considered themselves to be above the law. Instead of cooperating with the federal investigation to ensure that corrupt law enforcement officers would be brought to justice, the defendants in this case are accused of taking affirmative steps designed to ensure that light would not shine on illegal conduct that violated basic constitutional rights.”
Bill Lewis, the Assistant Director in Charge of the FBI’s Los Angeles Field Office, commented: “The defendants charged in this case are facing serious allegations, including violating the trust of the public they were sworn to serve. It is equally as important to point out that these charges should not reflect on the thousands of men and women of the Sheriff’s Department who proudly serve the citizens of Los Angeles County, and who partner with the FBI in a variety of crime areas.”
This morning, FBI agents took into custody 16 of the 18 defendants named in four indictments and one criminal complaint. Most of the defendants were arrested at various LASD facilities.
The five cases, which are part of an ongoing investigation, were unsealed this morning.
United States v. Brunsting and Branum, CR13-573
Two deputy sheriffs – Bryan Brunsting and Jason Branum – are charged in a six-count indictment with civil rights violations and making false statements in reports. Brunsting, who was a training officer, is charged in relation to an incident in which an inmate allegedly was assaulted and suffered bodily injury. Both Brunsting and Branum are charged in another assault. The victims were inmates at the Twin Towers Correctional Facility, where both deputies worked. Following the two incidents, the indictment alleges that Brunsting used deputies he was training to file reports that covered up the abuse.
United States v. Gonzalez, et al., CR13-574
This indictment charges a sergeant and four deputies with civil rights violations that allege they arrested or detained five victims – including the Austrian consul general – when they arrived to visit inmates at the Men’s Central Jail (MCJ) in 2010 and 2011.
The lead defendant in this indictment – Sergeant Eric Gonzalez, who was a supervisor in the MCJ visiting center, but no longer works for LASD – fostered an atmosphere “that encouraged and tolerated abuses of the law, including through the use of unjustified force and unreasonable searches and seizures by deputy sheriffs he supervised,” according to the indictment.
Each of the four deputies – Sussie Ayala, Fernando Luviano, Pantamitr Zunggeemoge and Noel Womack – is charged with participating in at least one of the four incidents in which victims allegedly suffered civil rights violations. In one incident, a man suffered a broken arm and a dislocated shoulder that has left him permanently disabled. In another incident, the Austrian consul general and her husband were handcuffed and detained.United States v. Thompson, et al., CR13-819
This six-count indictment that alleges a broad conspiracy to obstruct justice charges seven sworn members of the LASD. This case developed when deputies assigned to the Men’s Central Jail – including Lieutenant Gregory Thompson, who oversaw LASD’s Operation Safe Jails Program, and Lieutenant Stephen Leavins, who was assigned to the LASD’s Internal Criminal Investigations Bureau – learned that an inmate was an FBI informant and was acting as a cooperator in the FBI’s corruption and civil rights investigation.
After learning that the inmate received a cellular phone from a deputy sheriff who took a bribe and that the inmate was part of a civil rights investigation, those allegedly involved in the obstruction scheme took affirmative steps to hide the cooperator from the FBI and the United States Marshals Service, which was attempting to bring the inmate to testify before a federal grand jury in response to an order issued by a federal judge. As part of the conspiracy, the deputies allegedly altered records to make it appear that the cooperator had been released. They then re-booked the inmate under a different name, and then told the cooperator that he had been abandoned by the FBI.
Over the course of several weeks, the deputy sheriffs allegedly also attempted to obtain an order from a Los Angeles Superior Court judge that would have compelled the FBI to turn over information about its investigation to LASD. After the judge refused to issue such an order, according to the indictment, two LASD sergeants who are charged in this case nevertheless confronted an FBI special agent at her residence in an attempt to intimidate her into providing details about the investigation. The sergeants falsely told the special agent and her supervisor that they were obtaining a warrant for her arrest, according to the indictment.
Thompson no longer works for LASD. The other deputies named in this indictment are Gerard Smith, Mickey Manzo, and James Sexton, who were assigned to the Operation Safe Jails Program; and Scott Craig and Maricella Long, who were LASD sergeants within the Internal Criminal Investigations Bureau.
United States v. Piquette, CR13-821
Deputy Richard Piquette is charged in the fourth indictment with illegally building and possessing an assault rifle. The indictment charges Piquette with possessing an unregistered Noveske Rifleworks N-4 .223 caliber rifle with a barrel length of less than 16 inches. The second count in the indictment charges Piquette with manufacturing the Noveske rifle. Piquette, who is currently on leave with LASD, was previously assigned to the Twin Towers Correctional Facility. The investigation in this case was conducted by the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives.
United States v. Khounthavong, et al., 13-3105M
The fifth case unsealed today is a criminal complaint that charges three LASD deputies, all of whom are brothers, with conspiracy to make false statements to two banks in connection with a “buy-and-bail” mortgage fraud scheme. The complaint alleges that the three deputies – Billy Khounthavong, Benny Khounthavong, and Johnny Khounthavong – made false statements and reports to Flagstar Bank to purchase a 3,900-square-foot residence in Corona. The brothers then made additional false statements and reports to Bank of America in relation to another large residence they owned. The brothers walked away from – or “bailed” on – that home in which they were “under water,” meaning they owed substantially more than the residence was worth. As a result of the scheme, the brothers allegedly avoided more than $340,000 of unpaid mortgage debt. Benny Khounthavong and Johnny Khounthavong are assigned to LASD jail facilities.
An indictment contains allegations that a defendant has committed a crime. Every defendant is presumed innocent until and unless proven guilty.
The five cases announced today are part of an ongoing investigation being conducted by the Federal Bureau of Investigation.
Release No. 13-143
Members of Family Who Manufactured Homemade ‘Male Enhancement’ Drug Sentenced in Federal Conspiracy CaseRead the Press Release
LOS ANGELES – Three members of a Rowland Heights family involved in a home-based enterprise that manufactured a “male enhancement” drug that sold on the Internet and in retails stores nationwide have been sentenced for unlawfully importing tadalafil, the same active ingredient in the prescription drug Cialis.
Won Bae Kim, 61, was sentenced on Wednesday to 11 months in federal prison.
Two sons, Jong Ik Kim, 35, and Jong Heon Kim, 34, each were sentenced to one year probation, which will include six months of home detention.
The Kims were sentenced on Wednesday by United States District Judge Dean D. Pregerson, who also ordered Won Bae Kim to pay a $10,000 fine.
According to court documents, Won Bae Kim started a business named Kawa Health and imported pounds of tadalafil from China, which were used to manufacture a male enhancement drug that Kawa Health marketed under the name “Xzen 1200.” The tadalafil packages were delivered to commercial mailbox facilities, where the Kims were able to pick them up. After the Xzen 1200 pills were manufactured, Jong Ik Kim and Jong Heon Kim sold the drugs across the country, including to adult book stores. The packaging for the drugs did not disclose that tadalafil was an ingredient, which prompted the U.S. Food and Drug Administration to issue a warning about the product earlier this year. The investigation revealed that the Kims generated sales of more than $300,000 over a one-year period.
The operation was disrupted when U.S. Customs and Border Protection officials found that overseas packages intended for one of the mailboxes contained tadalafil. Agents of Department of Homeland Security’s Homeland Security Investigations then followed the delivery of the packages to a mailbox, when Won Bae Kim picked them up. Agents followed him back to his home and executed a search warrant, where they discovered large amounts of pills and packaging material for the Xzen product, as well as $13,000 in cash, which has been forfeited.
Release No. 13-139
Leader of Quarter-Billion Dollar Tax Fraud Scheme, Already Sentenced to 14 Years, Ordered to Pay $2.9 Million in RestitutionRead the Press Release
During Past 2 Years, 43 Defendants Linked to Inland Empire’s Old Quest Foundation Have Been Convicted, Including Attorney and 7 Tax Return Preparers.
SANTA ANA, California – Concluding sentencing proceedings in which he was already previously to serve a 14-year prison term, the former leader of the Fontana-based Old Quest Foundation was ordered this afternoon to pay $2,925,620 in restitution in relation to a tax fraud scheme that resulted in more than 400 fraudulent federal income tax returns being filed with the IRS that cumulatively sought more than $250 million in fraudulent refunds.
Arturo S. Ruiz, 55, of Moreno Valley, was sentenced by United States District Judge Josephine L. Staton, who issued the 168-month prison sentence on September 20.
The scheme run out of Old Quest was the largest tax refund fraud in history involving misuse of Original Issue Discount tax forms. The case against Ruiz and the other Old Quest defendants stems from Operation Stolen Treasures, an investigation conducted by Special Agents with IRS Criminal Investigation that led to 55 people being indicted by a federal grand jury in the fall of 2011.
Ruiz, who was the chief executive officer of Old Quest, was convicted at trial in January 2013 of one count of conspiracy to defraud the United States and 41 counts of filing false claims against the United States, including four of his own false federal tax returns. Old Quest’s president and second-in-command, Francisco J. Mendoza, also was convicted during the January trial, but died shortly before he was scheduled to be sentenced in November 2013.
Old Quest promoter Arturo Villarreal-Alba, 45, of Whittier, who was previously sentenced to eight years in prison, was ordered today to pay $462,239 in restitution to the IRS.
Also sentenced today was Old Quest promoter Ricardo Bonilla, 52, of Fontana , who received a prison term of 33 months.
The evidence presented at Ruiz and Mendoza’s trial and in court documents showed that Ruiz fraudulently told Old Quest customers they each could receive hundreds of thousands of dollars in tax refunds by accessing “secret government accounts” through a process that included the filing of IRS Forms 1099-OID. During presentations made across Southern California, members of the Old Quest conspiracy promoted the secret account theory and other “tax defier” arguments. In an attempt to give legitimacy to the scheme, Ruiz falsely told customers who attended seminars that Old Quest had employees who were attorneys, accountants, CPAs, and former IRS employees. Taxpayers who signed up were required to pay Old Quest fees as high as $10,000, and they were required to promise to “donate” to Old Quest 25 percent of any tax refunds they received.
In exchange for the payments, Old Quest prepared and filed false income tax returns, which routinely sought hundreds of thousands of dollars – and sometimes millions of dollars – in income tax refunds. In some cases, Old Quest filed multiple false tax returns on behalf of customers. During a search warrant executed at Old Quest’s offices, special agents with IRS Criminal Investigation seized several unfiled tax returns, including one signed tax return that falsely reported $10,500,106 in federal income tax had been withheld and fraudulently claimed a $6,868,675 tax refund. Although the IRS stopped most of the false refunds before they issued, several very large refunds issued, including one for $1,192,653.
Bank records and other evidence showed that Old Quest received approximately $2 million from customers who used the fraudulent OID scheme, as well as from tax refunds erroneously issued by the IRS. The evidence also showed that while IRS agents were searching Old Quest’s offices, Mendoza emptied more than $250,000 from one of Old Quest’s bank accounts, and then Ruiz hid those funds from authorities by depositing them into another bank account in a different name.
When customers received IRS letters warning that their tax returns were frivolous, Old Quest employees assured customers that the IRS sent letters only to “intimidate” them because the “IRS did not want to pay.” After several refund checks were erroneously issued and the IRS froze the bank accounts of the customers who had received them, Ruiz instructed their employees to open new accounts for customers at different banks in an attempt to avoid further IRS scrutiny. The IRS search of the Old Quest offices and computers in September 2009 revealed numerous emails and printouts of IRS publications warning of the exact same scheme that Ruiz was promoting.
Prior to the tax refund scheme, Ruiz had promoted a “land patent” program to many of the same customers, according to the evidence introduced at his trial. Under this fraudulent program, Ruiz promised to eliminate the customers’ mortgages through an obscure and mysterious process, again in exchange for substantial fees. The land patent program quickly failed, and dozens of customers lost their homes to foreclosure.
In addition to selling the fraudulent schemes to customers across the Southland, Ruiz and Mendoza failed to report hundreds of thousands of dollars of their own income, and Ruiz filed several false federal income tax returns for himself that fraudulently sought refunds. The evidence at trial showed that Ruiz bragged about not paying taxes for more than 25 years.Of the 55 defendants indicted as part of Operation Stolen Treasures, seven have been convicted at trial (which includes Mendoza), 36 have pleaded guilty, two have agreed to plead guilty, and eight are pending trial. One defendant remains a fugitive, and one defendant was acquitted.
Release No. 13-140
For Second Time in Federal Court, Long Beach Man Guilty of Transporting Women Across State Lines to Work as ProstitutesRead the Press Release
SANTA ANA, California – A Long Beach man with a long history of forcing women into the sex trade pleaded guilty this morning in a sex trafficking case and is expected to be sent to prison for another decade.
William Earl Flavors, also known as “Andre,” 40, who formerly resided in Seattle, pleaded guilty this morning to a charge of transportation into prostitution.
Flavors pleaded guilty before United States District Judge Josephine L. Staton, who scheduled a sentencing hearing for May 9. While Judge Staton will make the final decision, prosecutors and Flavors agree that the appropriate sentence in this case is the statutory maximum sentence of 10 years in federal prison. The 10-year sentence is much longer than the sentence that would be expected for this crime under the United States Sentencing Guidelines, and this 10-year sentence would run consecutive to a four-year sentence he is currently serving in relation to the same conduct.
In court this morning, Flavors admitted that he transported two victims in 2012 from Long Beach to Las Vegas, where they were forced or coerced to work as prostitutes. Flavors also admitted he used coercion and force – including physical abuse and threats of additional physical abuse – to make one of the victims work for him as a prostitute for an eight-month period in 2012.
In a previous case, Flavors was prosecuted by the United States Attorney’s Office and received a 14-year prison sentence in May 2000. In that case, Flavors admitted transporting two teen age girls from Washington and forcing them to work as prostitutes in Orange County.
Flavors completed his sentence in late 2011 and was on supervised release until October 2012, when he was arrested by Long Beach police after a woman reported being attacked by Flavors. Flavors pleaded guilty in state court last year to pimping in relation to his activities in 2012, and he was sentenced to four years in state prison.
Earlier this year, United States District Judge Cormac J. Carney found Flavors to be in violation of his supervised release in the prior federal court case. Judge Carney revoked his supervised release and sentenced Flavors to a four-year prison term, which he is currently serving.
The sentencing that Flavors will receive from Judge Staton in relation to today’s guilty plea will run consecutive to the sentence that he is currently serving.
The current case against Flavors was investigated by the Federal Bureau of Investigation and the Long Beach Police Department.
Release No. 13-138
Operators of Loan Modification Scam That Targeted Struggling Homeowners Arrested in $12 Million SchemeRead the Press Release
SANTA ANA, California – An attorney this morning became the third defendant taken into custody in relation to a scheme that offered bogus loan modification assistance to struggling homeowners.
Ronald Rodis, 49, of Irvine, surrendered this morning to federal agents on charges alleging that he participated in, and lent his name and the law license he formerly possessed to, the fraudulent operation. Rodis lost his license to practice law in California when he resigned from the State Bar in 2009.
Federal agents yesterday arrested Bryan D’Antonio, 47, of Brea, and Charles Wayne Farris, 53, of Aliso Viejo, for their roles in the operation of the Rodis Law Group and America’s Law Group, businesses that allegedly offered bogus loan modification assistance.
All three defendants were named in a federal indictment unsealed yesterday following an investigation by the FBI and IRS-Criminal Investigation.
As a result of the scheme, more than 1,800 financially distressed homeowners cumulatively lost at least $12 million in fees they paid to the companies, the indictment alleges. Many homeowners also lost their homes to foreclosure.
During a nine-month period that began in October 2008, the Rodis Law Group and America’s Law Group allegedly defrauded distressed homeowners by making false promises and guarantees regarding the companies’ ability to negotiate loan modifications from the homeowners’ mortgage lenders, falsely representing that a “team of attorneys” would represent the homeowners and advising homeowners to cease making their mortgage payments.
“Posing as successful lawyers, these defendants offered struggling homeowners false hopes and bogus promises of quality legal representation,” said United States Attorney André Birotte Jr. “The market offering loan modifications is rife with fraud, which is why we have redoubled our efforts to investigate and prosecute those who engage in financial crimes that target distressed homeowners.”
Bill Lewis, the Assistant Director in Charge of the FBI’s Los Angeles Field Office, said: “The unconscionable act of scamming homeowners already facing foreclosure is far too common. This indictment should send a clear message to anyone contemplating similar crimes, and should also remind potential victims to be cautious before paying fees to those offering financial rescue, regardless of whether the solicitor holds a law degree.”
The Rodis Law Group, and its successor company, America’s Law Group, allegedly advertised loan modification assistance on radio stations nationwide. According to the indictment, many of these radio advertisements featured Rodis’ voice telling homeowners that a team of experienced attorneys who were “highly skilled in negotiating lower interest rates and even lowering your principal balance” would negotiate with mortgage lenders. Farris and D’Antonio hired and trained salespeople who allegedly told homeowners that Rodis Law Group was “100% successful,” “routinely lowered monthly payments,” and obtained reduced principal balances. According to the indictment, once the defendants and their co-conspirators convinced homeowners to pay a fee of several thousand dollars, little to no effort was made to obtain loan modifications. After making their payments, homeowners who tried to get updates on the status of their cases were often unable to contact anyone at either company.
“These arrests send a strong message to those who would prey on vulnerable homeowners during these tough financial times,” said Assistant Attorney General for the Justice Department’s Civil Division Stuart F. Delery. “If you defraud homeowners, you will be found and brought to justice.”
The indictment further alleges that D’Antonio committed these crimes after having been convicted of mail and wire fraud in 2003 for his role in a previous telemarketing scheme. The previous scheme resulted in a civil case by the Federal Trade Commission and ultimately a 2001 court order that permanently banned D’Antonio from participating in future telemarketing operations. The indictment in this case alleges that D’Antonio committed criminal contempt of court by directing the telemarketing activities of Rodis Law Group and America’s Law Group and by misrepresenting the services they provided.
“The defendants found a way to defraud financially distressed homeowners out of $12 million in fees from their loan modification scam,” said Joel P. Garland, Acting Special Agent in Charge for IRS Criminal Investigation’s Los Angeles Field Office. “Be assured that IRS Criminal Investigation, together with our partners and the U.S. Attorney’s Office, will hold those who engage in similar behavior fully accountable.”
An indictment contains allegations that a defendant has committed a crime. Every defendant is presumed innocent until and unless proven guilty in court.
D’Antonio, Farris and Rodis are each charged with 10 felony counts – nine counts of wire fraud and one count of conspiracy. Each of these counts carries a statutory maximum penalty of 20 years in federal prison. In addition, D’Antonio is charged with 13 counts of criminal contempt for violating the 2001 court order. Criminal contempt of court has no statutory maximum penalty.
Rodis is expected to be arraigned on the indictment this afternoon in United States District Court in Santa Ana.
Following their arrests yesterday, D’Antonio and Farris were arraigned and entered not guilty pleas. A trial for both men was scheduled for January 28 before United States District Judge David O. Carter. At yesterday’s hearing, D’Antonio was ordered detained (held without bond), and Farris was released on a $60,000 bond.
This indictment was brought as part of the President’s Financial Fraud Enforcement Task Force’s Mortgage Fraud Working Group. The task force was established to wage an aggressive, coordinated and proactive effort to investigate and prosecute financial crimes. With more than 20 federal agencies, 94 U.S. attorneys’ offices and state and local partners, it’s the broadest coalition of law enforcement, investigatory and regulatory agencies ever assembled to combat fraud. Since its formation, the task force has made great strides in facilitating increased investigation and prosecution of financial crimes; enhancing coordination and cooperation among federal, state and local authorities; addressing discrimination in the lending and financial markets and conducting outreach to the public, victims, financial institutions and other organizations. For more information on the task force, please visit www.StopFraud.gov.
Release No. 13-137
Former Supplier of Beef to National School Lunch Program Settle Allegations of Improper Practices and Mistreating CowsRead the Press Release
LOS ANGELES -- Several California companies and individuals that formerly supplied beef to the National School Lunch Program have agreed to settle allegations of inhumane handling of cattle, circumventing appropriate inspection of nonambulatory disabled (“downer”) cattle and false representations regarding their eligibility to process beef, the Justice Department announced today. The announcement follows approval of the last of these settlements by a California probate court.
The settlements will conclude a lawsuit initiated by the Humane Society of the United States (HSUS) under the whistleblower provisions of the False Claims Act (FCA) after an HSUS investigator videotaped alleged inhumane cattle handling and improper downer cattle inspection practices at the slaughterhouse and meat processing facility of Westland Meat Co. and Hallmark Meat Packing Co. in Chino. The government later joined the lawsuit and brought additional claims that the defendants concealed their ineligibility to process beef because a convicted felon, Aaron “Arnie” Magidow, was a partner in and otherwise responsibly connected with the facility’s operations. U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) regulations applicable to suppliers of the National School Lunch Program prohibit the inhumane handling of cattle, require the proper inspection and disposition of downer cattle and require suppliers to identify convicted felons who are responsibly connected to the suppliers’ operations.
“The contractors who supply beef and other meat products to schools and child-care facilities have a responsibility to provide our nation’s young people with products that come only from healthy and humanely handled animals,” said United States Attorney André Birotte Jr. “This settlement holds accountable businesses that mistreated cows on a regular basis and routinely evaded a critically important USDA inspection procedure that allowed ‘downer cows’ to be processed into food.”
Stuart F. Delery, the Assistant Attorney General for the Justice Department’s Civil Division, said: “Children across the country depend on the National School Lunch Program to provide them with a healthy meal each day, so we all depend on companies providing food to the program to follow the rules designed to ensure those meals are safe to eat. The Justice Department will pursue aggressively anyone whose unlawful conduct puts the safety of our food at risk.”
The National School Lunch Program, administered by the USDA, is a federally assisted meal program operating in public and nonprofit private schools and residential child-care institutions. The program provides nutritionally balanced, low-cost or free lunches to children each school day. All ground beef containing the defendants’ products was recalled as of Feb. 16, 2008, and the defendants no longer supply beef to the National School Lunch Program.
“A top priority for USDA’s Office of Inspector General (OIG) is protecting the integrity of America’s food supply by investigating violations of the Federal Meat Inspection Act,” said USDA-OIG Western Region Special Agent in Charge Lori Chan. “Agents from OIG’s Diamond Bar office conducted an extensive investigation of the Hallmark/Westland facility, which supplied ground beef to schools through USDA’s National School Lunch Program. The government’s joint investigation led to one of the largest civil settlements in OIG’s history.”
Under the settlements, Westland Meat Co., based in Corona Del Mar, and its owner, Steve Mendell, will pay $240,000, and Westland will enter into a consent judgment for $155.68 million. M&M Management, also based in Corona Del Mar; Cattleman’s Choice, based in Commerce; the estate of Cattleman’s deceased owner, Arnie Magidow; and Magidow’s surviving spouse will pay a total of approximately $2.45 million. Magidow’s surviving spouse was named in the lawsuit as a successor in interest to Magidow and is not alleged to have engaged in any wrongdoing. In October 2012, defendants Donald R. Hallmark and Donald W. Hallmark settled allegations for $304,130.
The FCA’s whistleblower provisions, under which HSUS filed the lawsuit, permit a private entity to bring a lawsuit on behalf of the government and to share in any proceeds from the suit. The FCA also allows the government to intervene in the lawsuit, as it has done in this case. As a result of the settlements announced today, HSUS will receive approximately $600,000.
The case was handled by the U.S. Attorney’s Office for the Central District of California and the Justice Department’s Civil Division, Commercial Litigation Branch; in cooperation with the USDA Office of Inspector General. The claims resolved by the settlement are allegations only; there has been no determination of liability.
Release No. 13-136
Former United Airlines Flight Attendant Sentenced to Federal Prison for Making Bogus Bomb Threats Aimed at His Former EmployerRead the Press Release
LOS ANGELES -- A German national who used to work for United Airlines was sentenced today to 18 months in federal prison for making false bomb threats against flights operated by the international air carrier.
Patrick Cau, who is also known as Patrick Kaiser, 40, of Dallas, was sentenced by United States District Judge Otis D. Wright II.
Cau pleaded guilty in August to one count of false information and hoaxes. While Cau pleaded guilty to one felony count, in a plea agreement filed in federal court, he admitted making eight bomb threats against United from October 2012 through January 2013.
In the first phone call, on October 4, 2012, Cau used a pay phone near his home to call an internal United crew scheduling number and state that a United flight from London to Los Angeles would be bombed later that day. Cau made the subsequent calls to 911 from pay phones in Los Angeles, New York City, Las Vegas and Seattle, with all of the calls stating that a specific United flight would be bombed.
As a result of the hoaxes, multiple law enforcement agencies were forced to respond to the bomb threats made by Cau. These law enforcement responses included evacuating people from the targeted airplanes; towing the aircraft to a safe area; searching and re-screening passengers, baggage and cargo; and searching the aircraft by human, canine and other detection methods.
As a direct result of Cau’s threats, United experienced substantial disruption to its business operations and services, including cancellation of and delays to flights, transfer of aircraft, and significant inconveniences to United passengers. Judge Wright today ordered Cau to pay $304,495 in restitution to United and $8,838 to reimburse the Los Angeles Police Department for expenses incurred as a result its response to the bomb threats.
The case against Cau was investigated by the Federal Bureau of Investigation; U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement’s (ICE) Homeland Security Investigations (HSI), and the Los Angeles Airport Police.
Release No. 13-135
Pomona Resident Previously Convicted in Child Exploitation Case Indicted for Illegally Possessing Weapons CacheRead the Press Release
LOS ANGELES -- An Army veteran who was convicted of possessing child pornography after a court martial was indicted today on federal charges of being a felon in possession of firearms and ammunition.
Ky Cheng, 43, of Pomona, was named in a one-count indictment that charges him with illegally possessing a cache of weapons. If he is convicted of the charge, he would face a maximum statutory penalty of 10 years in federal prison.
The case stems from a probation search of Cheng’s residence on August 14, 2013. Law enforcement officials from the Pomona Police Department, the United States Marshals Service, the Los Angeles County Probation Department, the Los Angeles County District Attorney’s Office, and the California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation conducted the search and found weapons that prompted the Sheriff’s Department Bomb Squad to respond. As a result of the weapons discovered during the search, the FBI San Gabriel Valley Safe Streets Gang Task Force was brought in to investigate.
The indictment alleges that Cheng illegally possessed eight .45-caliber handguns, two 12-gauge shotguns, one .308-caliber rifle, 46 high-capacity ammunition magazines and approximately 1,200 rounds ammunition.
Cheng was convicted of possession of child pornography in 2007, and he was convicted in Los Angeles Superior Court of failing to register as a sex offender in 2010.
Cheng is currently in the Los Angeles County Jail serving a three-year sentence imposed for violating the terms of his probation in the 2010 case.Release No. 13-134a
Two Men Who Operated Credit Card Fraud Rings Based in San Gabriel Valley Sentenced to Federal PrisonRead the Press Release
LOS ANGELES – A San Gabriel Valley man involved in credit card fraud was sentenced this morning to 87 months in federal prison for heading a credit card fraud ring that used stolen credit card numbers from around the world to buy hundreds of thousands of dollars of luxury goods, cosmetics, electronics and other merchandise at retail stores.
With the 7¼-year sentence, Zhanghang Wu (吳章航) becomes the second man this month sentenced to prison in federal court in Los Angeles for operating a fraudulent credit card ring.
Wu, 38, who at the time of the offenses was residing in Alhambra, was sentenced by United States District Judge John A. Kronstadt. Wu, who was also known as "Leo Han," pleaded guilty in December 2012 to conspiracy and credit card fraud.
The second credit card scammer, Xiaoliang Chen (陳曉亮), 27, of Monterey Park, was sentenced on November 4 to 51 months in federal prison for leading a similar operation that used stolen credit card numbers and counterfeit cards to bilk financial institutions from around the world.
The operations involving Wu and Chen involved losses that are estimated to be approximately $1.5 million, with Wu being responsible for just over $1 million of those losses.
Wu and Chen each led rings that received credit card numbers that had been stolen from bank customers around the world. That stolen information was used to manufacture counterfeit credit cards that bore the names of “runners” -- co-conspirators who went to retails stores, including Nordstrom, Macy’s, Apple, and Abercrombie & Fitch -- who used the fake cards to make fraudulent transactions. After the runners purchased items with the counterfeit credit cards, they either returned the goods for credit, or the goods were sold to other parties.
An investigation into fraudulent credit card use in the San Gabriel Valley led by the United States Secret Service generated information that Wu and Chen may be involved in organized fraud rings. Wu had earlier been associated with a credit card fraud operation that had been uncovered during an investigation by Chinese authorities. In March 2012, Secret Service agents searched the homes of Wu and Chen, where they discovered machines for making credit cards and computers containing credit card information.
In July 2012, Secret Service agents arrested Wu in Las Vegas, Nevada, where he had fled after the search of his residence and where he continued to engage in credit card fraud. Wu had been living in casino hotels for several weeks, and at the time of his arrest was in the process of sending a group of runners to Chicago to continue the scheme.
Chen was arrested in August 2012, also in Las Vegas, by Secret Service agents.
During the course of the investigation, the Secret Service received information from the Chinese Ministry of Public Security, Economic Crimes Investigation Division, about their investigation of credit card fraud in China.
Joseph Beaty, the special agent in charge of the United States Secret Service, Los Angeles District, acknowledged the cooperation provided by the Chinese Ministry of Public Security and the People’s Republic of China. Without the assistance of the Chinese authorities, the complete investigation and prosecution of this case would not have been possible, Beaty said.
This case is the product of an investigation by the U.S. Secret Service, which also received assistance from the United States Postal Inspection Service.
Release No. 13-133a
Man Who Arranged Sham Marriages Between Nigerians and U.S. Citizens Found Guilty of Immigration FraudRead the Press Release
LOS ANGELES – A Los Angeles man was found guilty today of six felony immigration-related offenses for illegally arranging sham marriages that allowed Nigerian nationals to fraudulently obtain legal permanent residency in the United States.
Alake “Terry” Ilegbameh, 46, a resident of the Baldwin Hills district of Los Angeles, was found guilty of six counts of conspiracy to violate immigration laws.
Ilegbameh was convicted by a federal jury following a six-day trial before United States District Judge Michael W. Fitzgerald, who is scheduled to sentence the defendant on February 24. At sentencing, Ilegbameh faces a statutory maximum penalty of 30 years in federal prison.
Prosecutors proved at trial that Ilegbameh arranged sham marriages for the purpose of obtaining permanent resident status for six Nigerian immigrants. Ilegbameh recruited American citizens who agreed to marry an African immigrant for money – typically offering the U.S. citizens $1,000 or more – and Ilegbameh actively participated in schemes to make the resulting marriages appear legitimate to immigration officials.
As part of the scheme, Ilegbameh instructed the Nigerians and the Americans in the sham marriages how to make their relationships appear genuine by opening joint bank accounts or other accounts, obtaining identification with matching addresses, and taking photographs together. Ilegbameh made arrangements for the couples to see immigrations attorneys, who would file visa petitions and applications for adjustment of status containing false statements to U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS). After Ilegbameh concluded that federal agents were conducting an investigation, he instructed some of the Americans involved in the marriages to lie to investigators and he threatened them that they would go to jail if they withdrew from the sham marriages.
“Hollywood likes to glamorize marriage fraud, but as this defendant discovered, in real life these schemes don’t have happy endings,” said Claude Arnold, special agent in charge for Homeland Security Investigations (HSI) Los Angeles. “Immigration benefit fraud is a serious crime. Not only do these activities undermine the integrity of our nation’s legal immigration system, they also pose a significant security vulnerability.”
The investigation into Ilegbameh’s activities was conducted by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement’s Homeland Security Investigations.
Release No. 13-134
17 Ventura County Gang Members Linked to Mexican Mafia Charged for Roles in Mexican-Based Drug Trafficking Organization Operation “SuperNova” Targeted Gang-Related Drug TraffickingRead the Press Release
LOS ANGELES – In the third phase of Operation “SuperNova,” a multi-agency task force investigation that targeted Mexican Mafia-affiliated street gangs in Ventura County, 17 people have been charged following an investigation by a task force comprised of the FBI, the Ventura Police Department and the Oxnard Police Department. Following arrests this morning, 14 of 17 defendants named in a federal criminal complaint unsealed this morning are now in custody.
Several teams of police officers and federal agents executed arrest and search warrants early this morning and took six defendants into custody without incident. Eight of the 17 defendants charged were already in custody based on unrelated charges and soon will be brought into federal custody. The remaining three defendants charged in the complaint are fugitives, some believed to be residing in Mexico, where they allegedly direct the narcotics-trafficking activity alleged in the complaint.
The criminal complaint details a year-long undercover investigation and outlines a series of narcotics transactions that led to the seizure of more than two pounds of methamphetamine and quantities of heroin that were being sold on the streets of Ventura County. The complaint alleges that the drugs were supplied by a Mexican drug trafficking organization controlled by Mexican Mafia member Martin Madrigal-Cazares. Local street gangs allegedly communicated with the head of the organization in Mexico, while controlling narcotics sales and collecting “taxes” on behalf of the Mexican Mafia in Ventura County.
This case targeted the "shotcallers" of Ventura County and Oxnard street gangs -- including Lemonwood, Surtown and Ventura Avenue Gangsters -- whose members control the drug trade in their respective territories. The defendants charged in the complaint (with the exception of Cazares) are residents of Ventura, Oxnard, Camarillo and Moorpark. Those named are: David Acosta, 33, in custody;
Daniel Armendariz, 38, arrested today;
Pedro Arrieta, 42, arrested today
Robert De La Cerda, 35, in custody
Lina Fuentes, 35, fugitive;
Daniel Gonzales, 40, in custody;
Philip Guerra, 28, arrested today;
Ruben Hernandez, 20, in custody;
Alejandro Herrera, 38, in custody;
David Leal, David, 44, arrested today;
Martin Madrigal-Cazares, 38, a fugitive believed to be residing in Mexico;
Dillon Mansell, 21, in custody;
Armando Molina, 30, arrested today;
Edwin Mora, 29, in custody;
Librado Navarrete, 27, a fugitive;
Frank Ruiz, 32, arrested today; and
Javier Tamayo, 35, in custody
As a result of the first phase of Operation Supernova in 2011(see: http://www.justice.gov/usao/cac/pressroom/pr2011/018.html), 11 defendants were convicted and received sentences of up to 25 years in prison. In the second phase of Operation Supernova in 2012 (see: http://www.fbi.gov/losangeles/press-releases/2011/oxnard-gang-members-arrested-on-federal-drug-and-gun-trafficking-charges-in-second-part-of-operation-supernova), six defendants were charged in connection with conspiracy to distribute methamphetamine and illegally sell firearms. The total seizure for the three-phase operation totals 18 pounds of methaphetamine, five kilograms of cocaine, six pounds of heroin and 46 firearms.
The defendants named in the complaint are charged conspiring to distribute methamphetamine and, if they are convicted, each would face a mandatory minimum sentence of 10 years in federal prison and a statutory maximum sentence of life in prison.
The defendants arrested today will make their initial appearances this afternoon in United States District Court in Los Angeles. The federal defendants will be prosecuted by the United States Attorney’s Office.
The investigation was conducted jointly by the Ventura Police Department; the Oxnard Police Department; and the FBI.
The Ventura Gang Task Force is one of many FBI Safe Streets Task Forces throughout the United States, funded for the purpose of assisting local police in identifying and addressing violent crime in America.
A criminal complaint contains allegations that a defendant has committed a crime. Every defendant is presumed to be innocent until and unless proven guilty in a court of law.
Release No. 13-133
Nursing Home Operator Agrees to Pay $48 Million to Resolve Allegations That Six SoCal Facilities Billed for Unnecessary TherapyRead the Press Release
LOS ANGELES – A Mission Viejo-based corporation that operates nursing homes across the western United States has agreed to pay $48 million to resolve allegations that it knowingly submitted inflated bills to Medicare for therapy services that were medically unnecessary or were never provided to elderly patients at six of its Southern California skilled nursing facilities.
The settlement comes in a case against The Ensign Group, Inc. that was unsealed late Monday by a federal judge in Los Angeles.
The Ensign Group operated skilled nursing facilities that allegedly submitted false claims to Medicare. Between January 1, 1999, and August 31, 2011, the six Ensign facilities allegedly submitted false claims to the government for physical, occupational and speech therapy services provided to Medicare beneficiaries that were not medically necessary. The government alleged that certain patients were kept in these facilities for periods of time that exceeded what was medically necessary for the treatment of their conditions.
The six Ensign facilities named in two federal “whistleblower” lawsuits are the Atlantic Memorial Healthcare Center in Long Beach, Panorama Gardens in Panorama City, Orchard Post Acute Care (commonly called Royal Court) in Whittier, Sea Cliff Healthcare Center in Huntington Beach, Southland in Norwalk, and Victoria Care Center in Ventura.
The lawsuit specifically alleged that Ensign improperly incentivized therapists and others to increase the amount of therapy provided to patients to meet planned targets for Medicare revenue, which were set without regard to patients' individual therapy needs and could only be achieved by billing at the highest reimbursement levels.
The six facilities also allegedly submitted claims for services that were not provided.
“The case against The Ensign Group involves a company that regularly bilked Medicare by submitting inflated bills that, in some cases, sought money for services that simply were never provided to patients,” said United States Attorney André Birotte Jr. “This settlement – one of the largest of its kind in United States history – demonstrates our commitment to protecting taxpayers who fund important programs that benefit millions of Americans, but don’t want to see their hard-earned money wasted on fraud or abuse.”
Glenn R. Ferry, Special Agent in Charge for the Los Angeles Region of the Office of Inspector General of the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. “Billing Medicare for costly, unnecessary skilled nursing services – as the government alleged here – inflates health care costs borne by taxpayers,” said “This settlement again puts on notice those who would consider defrauding federally funded health care programs.”
Ensign has entered into a Corporate Integrity Agreement with the HHS Inspector General’s Office.
“Skilled nursing facilities that place their own financial interests above the needs of their patients will be held accountable,” said Assistant Attorney General for the Justice Department’s Civil Division, Stuart F. Delery. “We will continue to advocate for the appropriate use of Medicare funds and the proper care of our senior citizens.”
The settlement resolves lawsuits filed by two former Ensign employees under the qui tam, – or whistleblower – provisions of the False Claims Act, which allow private citizens to bring suit on behalf of the government and share in any recovery. It has yet to be determined how much money the whistleblowers in this case, Gloria Patterson and Carol Sanchez, will receive in United States of America ex rel. Gloria Patterson v. Ensign Group, Inc., SACV 06-6956-CJC (Central District of California) and United States of America ex rel. Carol Sanchez v. Ensign Group, Inc., SACV 06-0643-CJC (Central District of California).
The case was resolved by the United States Attorney’s Office, with assistance from the Commercial Litigation Branch, Civil Division, U.S. Department of Justice; and the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services’ Office of Inspector General.
In settling these cases, Ensign did not admit liability.
Release No. 13-131
Former Animal Planet Television Network Host Pleads Guilty to Federal Charge of Selling Endangered WildlifeRead the Press Release
LOS ANGELES -- Donald Schultz, the former host of Animal Planet’s “Wild Recon” television show, pleaded guilty today in federal court to one count of violating the Endangered Species Act for selling two desert monitor lizards (Varanus griseus).
Schultz, 35, of Playa Vista, admitted in court that on July 29, 2010, he sold the two live desert monitor lizards to an undercover agent with the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service who was posing as a prospective buyer. After meeting with the undercover agent at his residence to finalize the deal, Schultz agreed to ship the two live desert monitors from Los Angeles to Buffalo, New York, via airplane A federal agent then received the monitors in New York and took them into custody.
Schultz had never been issued a permit to sell the two lizards. Desert monitor lizards are listed as endangered under the Endangered Species Act.
Schultz is scheduled to be sentenced by United States Magistrate Judge Victor B. Kenton on January 28.
Pursuant to the plea agreement, Schultz has agreed to serve two years of probation, pay a $6,000 fine, pay restitution of $3,000, and perform 200 hours of community service.
This case was investigated by the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service.
Release No. 13-132
Pomona Gang Member Pleads Guilty to Federal Weapons and Drug Offenses in Deal Expected to Bring Sentence of up to 17½ YearsRead the Press Release
LOS ANGELES – A Pomona man pleaded guilty today to a federal drug trafficking charge for possessing more than one-half pound of methamphetamine that he was planning to distribute.
Raymond Anthony Montanez, 24, pleaded guilty today to possession with intent to distribute methamphetamine and being a felon in possession of a firearm.
Montanez pleaded guilty before United States District Judge Philip S. Gutierrez, who is scheduled to sentence the defendant on February 10. As part of the plea agreement that led to this morning’s guilty pleas, prosecutors and Montanez agree that he will be sentenced to at least 10 years in federal prison and up to 17½ years in custody. The actual sentence will be determined by Judge Gutierrez next year.
Authorities recovered 243.7 grams of methamphetamine from Montanez’s residence on July 29, 2012 after he had shot himself in the leg and was brought to the hospital for treatment. Pomona Police Officers investigating the incident responded to his residence, recovered the weapon that Montanez used to shoot himself, found two other firearms, and discovered the narcotics.
The firearms charge relates to Montanez’s possession of a firearm on July 4, 2012. He prohibited from possessing any guns because was previously convicted of a felony in 2008 in state court of carrying a loaded handgun.
The case against Montanez is the result of an investigation by the San Gabriel Valley Safe Streets Gang Task Force, which is made up of agents and officers from the Federal Bureau of Investigation; the Pomona Police Department; the Drug Enforcement Administration; the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives; the Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Department; and the California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation.
Release No. 13-129
Orange County Ambulance Company Pays More Than $3 Million to Settle Allegations That It Overbilled Federal Health Care ProgramsRead the Press Release
SANTA ANA, California – An Orange County-based ambulance company has paid the United States more than $3 million to settle a lawsuit alleging it received overpayments from the Medicare program and other federal healthcare programs for transporting patients who were not eligible for ambulance transports, United States Attorney André Birotte Jr. announced today.
A federal judge in Santa Ana on Friday unsealed a lawsuit filed under the False Claims Act against ambulance transport company FILYN Corporation, which does business under the name Lynch Ambulance and is based in Anaheim. Lynch Ambulance and two of its principals named in the lawsuit settled the case. On November 7 Lynch Ambulance paid $3.05 million to the United States to resolve allegations that from 2001 through 2007 it regularly billed Medicare and other federal healthcare programs for transporting patients who were not “bed-confined” or whose transports otherwise were not medically necessary. The federal health care programs that paid claims for medically unnecessary transports were Medicare, TRICARE and the Federal Employees Health Benefits Program.
The settlement resolves a lawsuit filed under the qui tam – or “whistleblower” – provisions of the federal False Claims Act, which allow private citizens with knowledge of fraud to bring civil actions on behalf of the United States and to share in any recovery. The lawsuit -- which was filled by two former Lynch Ambulance employees, Jamie Weatherly and Dawn Lucero -- was unsealed after the United States elected to take over part of the case and negotiated the settlement.
Lynch Ambulance has also entered into a Corporate Integrity Agreement with the Department of Health and Human Services. Glenn R. Ferry, Special Agent in Charge for the Los Angeles Region of the Office of Inspector General for the Department of Health of Human Services, said: “Taxpayers shouldn't be on the hook for these expensive and medically unnecessary ambulance trips. Count on federal law enforcement to aggressively investigate and prosecute such actions.”
Lynch Ambulance and its principals have resolved this case without admitting any wrongdoing.
The settlement with Lynch Ambulance is the result of an investigation by the United States Department of Health and Human Services, Office of the Inspector General; the Department of Defense, Office of the Inspector General; the Office of Personnel Management, Office of the Inspector General; and the Federal Bureau of Investigation.
Release No. 13-130
Former Resident of Orange, CA Convicted of Scheme to Defraud Religious Order of Roman Catholic SistersRead the Press Release
SANTA ANA - Linda Rose Gagnon, also known as Linda Gualtieri-Gagnon, age 59, a former resident of Orange, CA, was convicted today by a jury on three counts of Wire Fraud, in violation of Title 18, United States Code, Section 1343. Ms. Gagnon’s trial occurred before the Hon. Andrew J. Guilford in the Ronald Reagan Courthouse of the Central District of California.
The jury found that Ms. Gagnon executed a scheme to defraud the U.S. Province of the Religious of Jesus and Mary (“RJM”), an order of Roman Catholic Sisters devoted to educational and charitable work, out of $285,000, which the RJM had set aside for the care of elderly and infirm Sisters. According to the evidence, Gagnon represented that she was an expert in handling short sale and foreclosure transactions and offered to assist RJM buy a small home in San Diego for use by retired and infirm Sisters.
The evidence presented at trial demonstrated that, contrary to her promises, Gagnon did not use the RJM’s funds to purchase the retirement home for the Sisters. Instead, Gagnon used the funds to pay for her personal expenses and to fund the unprofitable operations of her real estate finance company, Rose Enterprise, Inc. After only 64 days, Gagnon spent the entire sum of the RJM’s $285,000. The evidence showed that Gagnon used the RJM’s funds for Gagnon’s personal expenses, including travel, lingerie, groceries, manicures, hair dressing, restaurants, lease payments for an Audi TT sports car, and valet pet-sitting services for her dog. The RJM monies were also used to pay salaries, office rent, and supplies for Rose Enterprise, Inc.
After stringing out RJM for months and not disclosing her fraudulent misappropriation of RJM’s funds, Gagnon asked RJM for another $285,000 to buy the San Diego residence, falsely representing that she needed the additional funds because RJM’s original $285,000 was tied up in a “triple escrow” on another property.
Ms. Gagnon’s sentencing date is scheduled for February 24, 2014, at 3:00 p.m. The maximum penalty for Ms. Gagnon is 60 years in prison, 20 years for each count charged.
The case was investigated by the Federal Bureau of Investigation.
Release No. 13-128
Gang Leader Sentenced to 25 Years in Federal Prison in RICO CaseRead the Press Release
LOS ANGELES -- A Los Angeles man who was the leader of a criminal street gang that used violence and intimidation in an attempt to control the Pueblo del Rio Housing Projects in South Los Angeles was sentenced today to 25 years in federal prison.
Kevin Eleby, who was known on the street as “L,” 49, a longtime leader of the Pueblo Bishop Bloods street gang, was sentenced by United States District Judge S. James Otero. During a 10-year period of supervised release that will follow his prison term, Eleby will be banned from entering the Pueblo del Rio Housing Projects, the veritable headquarters of the gang.
Eleby was convicted in October 2012 of four felony charges: conspiracy to violate the federal Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations (RICO) ACT; conspiracy to distribute cocaine, crack cocaine and heroin; possession with the intent to distribute crack cocaine; and possession of a firearm in furtherance of a crime of violence.
The gun offense related to a shooting in which members of the gang used a Thompson submachine gun and other weapons to fire more than a dozen rounds into a residence in the projects where a rival gang member lived. Only the mother and 11-year-old brother of the intended victim were home at the time of the attack. Both victims survived, but the family moved out of the projects shortly thereafter. The evidence at trial showed that the shooting followed a gang meeting where Eleby passionately advocated that younger gang members needed to increase their retaliatory violence against rival gangs and drive Hispanic residents out of the projects.
Eleby was one of three defendants convicted following a four-week trial. The jury determined the Eleby and his co-defendants were members of a criminal enterprise that engaged in drug dealing, firearms trafficking, murder, witness intimidation and armed robbery as part of the gang’s efforts to control and terrorize the housing projects. Co-defendant Jason Davis was sentenced by Judge Otero on July 29 to 25 years in federal prison. The third person convicted at that trial -- Rashaad Laws, also known as “Big Time” -- is scheduled to be sentenced on December 9.
As a result of the federal investigation into the Pueblo Bishop Bloods, a total of 45 defendants were charged in federal indictments. Prosecutors have convicted 40 of those defendants, while two defendants are in state custody and two others are fugitives.
The final defendant in this case -- Rondale Young, who is accused of executing a young man with no gang affiliation by shooting the victim in front of the victim’s 2-year-old son, among other racketeering charges -- is scheduled to be tried before Judge Otero on December 3.
This case against members and associates of the Pueblo Bishop Bloods is the result of an investigation by the Los Angeles Metropolitan Task Force on Violent Gangs and other agencies, including, the Federal Bureau of Investigation, the Los Angeles Police Department, the United States Department of Housing and Urban Development - Office of Inspector General, and the Los Angeles County District Attorney’s Office.
Release No. 13-127
Former Member of Moreno Valley City Council Agrees to Plead Guilty to Federal Bribery Charge for Taking $2.3 Million Cash PaymentRead the Press Release
RIVERSIDE, California – In a case stemming from what is believed to be the largest bribe ever accepted by a public official in an undercover operation, a former member of the Moreno Valley City Council has agreed to plead guilty to a federal bribery charge for taking a $2.36 million cash payment from an undercover operative posing as a real estate broker.
Marcelo Co, 64, was charged this morning with one bribery count and one count of filing a false corporate tax return. In court documents filed this morning in United States District Court, Co agreed to plead guilty to the two charges that could send him to federal prison for as long as 13 years.
“Mr. Co orchestrated an elaborate and brazen scheme to undermine the democratic process in Moreno Valley,” said United States Attorney André Birotte Jr. “Whether he was motivated by power or greed, these crimes constitute a wholesale violation of his oath to work for the citizens who elected him.”
Co, who was elected to the City Council in November 2010 and resigned from his seat in August after being charged in state court in an unrelated welfare fraud case, is expected to make his initial court appearance in the federal bribery case early next month.
“It is a very sad day for the citizens of Moreno Valley when one of their elected council members sacrifices his legal and ethical obligations for power and greed,” said Riverside County District Attorney Paul Zellerbach. “This type of unlawful conduct by Mr. Coe undermines the very fabric of good government and what we all hope and expect from our elected officials.”
The case against Co is the result of an ongoing investigation by the Inland Regional Corruption Task Force, which is comprised of prosecutors, agents and investigators from the Federal Bureau of Investigation, IRS – Criminal Investigation, the Riverside County District Attorney’s Office and the United States Attorney’s Office.
“Mr. Co regularly traded votes, land and confidential information in exchange for cash to fund his personal bank account, rather than what was in the best interest of the residents of Moreno Valley," said Bill Lewis, the Assistant Director in Charge of the FBI’s Los Angeles Field Office. "This case was a result of seamless collaboration by the Inland Regional Corruption Task Force, whose members share a mission of rooting out corruption across the Inland Empire."
The court documents filed this morning outline a bribery scheme in which Co told a businessman and an undercover FBI operative posing as a real estate broker that he would control a voting majority of the Moreno Valley City Council and would be able to guarantee land use decisions that would benefit the businessman and the land broker. Co also promised to always vote in favor of land use decisions that would benefit the real estate broker.
Co solicited campaign donations from the businessman, who was cooperating with the investigation, and the FBI undercover operative. Co eventually received payments of $5,000 and $10,000 that he said were to be used to finance the campaigns of individuals who would vote with him on land use issues.
In the fall of 2012, Co met with the undercover operative to discuss a multimillion dollar sale of a 30-acre parcel that he owned. Co told the real estate broker that once he had control of the City Council, he could change the zoning of the property and the land value would dramatically increase. With the City Council election in November 2012, Co told the undercover investigator that he had the votes to alter the zoning and increase the value of Co’s 30-acre parcel, which had been appraised at $710,000. Co proposed that the undercover operative purchase the property for $5.36 million, which would include a cash payment of $2.36 million.
At a meeting on January 30, 2013, Co agreed to sell the property for $5.36 million, but that the publicly filed documents would reflect a sale price of only $3 million. At this meeting, Co accepted $2.36 million in cash.
The tax charge that was filed today concerns a United States Corporation Income Tax Return (Form 1120) that Co filed for his company, Qwik Pack Systems, for tax year 2010. In that filing with the IRS, Co failed to report well over $100,000 in income. This tax charge is not related to the bribery scheme.
“Mr. Co’s intentional omission of more than $112,000 in taxable income – and failure to pay $31,000 in tax to the IRS – was committed for his own private gain and was an insult to honest taxpayers and the citizens of Moreno Valley,” said Joel P. Garland, Acting Special Agent in Charge for IRS - Criminal Investigation, Los Angeles Field Office. “Today’s action is an example of IRS-CI’s vigilance when it comes to enforcing tax laws, particularly when it involves our public officials. IRS-CI, in partnership with our law enforcement partners, is committed to bringing to justice public officials who use their political office to commit crimes.”
At Co’s initial appearance in federal court, which is expected to be in early December, the case will be assigned to a District Judge who will schedule a hearing for Co to formally enter the guilty pleas.
Release No. 13-126
Leader of Avenues Gang Sentenced to 25 Years in Prison in Federal Racketeering Case for Murder and Ordering A KillingRead the Press Release
LOS ANGELES – The one-time top leader of the Avenues gang in Northeast Los Angeles and the lead defendant in a federal racketeering indictment who admitted murdering a rival gang member and ordered the killing of one his underlings was sentenced this morning to 25 years in federal prison.
Rudy Aguirre Jr., also known as “Lil Psycho,” 32, who is a high-ranking associate of the Mexican Mafia with strong family ties to the prison gang, was sentenced by United States District Judge George H. Wu.
Aguirre is one of the last defendants to be sentenced in relation to a 2009 racketeering indictment that charged 88 linked to the Avenues street gang in northeast Los Angeles (see: http://www.justice.gov/archive/usao/cac/Pressroom/pr2009/115.html). The wide-ranging racketeering case alleged a host of crimes, including the August 2008 murder of Los Angeles Sheriff’s Deputy Juan Escalante and the killings of several other victims. Most of the other defendants named in the indictment have previously been sentenced, receiving prison terms of up to 25 years. A co-defendant – Carlos Renterria, who admitted that he shot two rival gang members in the head at close range in an attempt to murder them, and that he plotted to murder a fellow Avenues gang member – also received a quarter-century prison term from Judge Wu earlier this month.
According to court documents, including his plea agreement, Aguirre was authorized by the Mexican Mafia to control the activities of the Avenues street gang on the street. As the leader of the Avenues, Aguirre would regularly meet with members of the Mexican Mafia at California penal institutions, where he would receive instructions and authorizations for certain violent crimes, and where he would relay information regarding the activities of the Avenues gang. Among other things, Aguirre was given the authority for designating individuals to collect extortionate “taxes” from drug dealers and others living and working in the area claimed by the Avenues gang. These “taxes” would then be funneled to the Mexican Mafia.
As part of his role in the Avenues, Aguirre shot and killed a rival gang member in 1999. Aguirre was charged with that murder in state court, but the charges against him were dismissed based on pre-trial rulings in that case. Aguirre subsequently was charged with that murder as part of federal case brought under the Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations Act (the federal RICO statute), and in July he pleaded guilty in the federal case, admitting that he fatally shot the victim in the Cyprus Park area of northeast Los Angeles.
Aguirre also admitted that he authorized the 2008 murder of an Avenues member because he and others believed that man was skimming money that he collected as “taxes” on behalf of the Avenues gang and the Mexican Mafia.
“No matter what steps criminal gangs like the Mexican Mafia and the Avenues use in attempts to control neighborhoods through intimidation and violence, we will ensure that the residents do not need to live their lives and raise their families in fear,” said United States Attorney André Birotte Jr. “I am proud that my office played an instrumental role in bringing justice to a predator responsible for two murders and overseeing a gang that caused so much harm to northeast Los Angeles.”
The federal investigation into the Avenues gang that led to the RICO case was conducted by the Los Angeles HIDTA (High Intensity Drug Trafficking Area) Task Force and the Los Angeles Police Department. The HIDTA group that conducted the investigation is made up of agents and officers from the Drug Enforcement Administration, U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement’s Homeland Security Investigations, IRS - Criminal Investigation, the Ontario Police Department, the Riverside Police Department, the San Bernardino County Sheriff’s Department and the Riverside County Sheriff’s Department.
The federal investigation into the Avenues began after the August 2, 2008 murder of Los Angeles Sheriff’s Deputy Juan Able Escalante, who was shot outside his Cypress Park home as he was getting ready to go to work at the Men’s Central Jail. Based on a collaborative effort by federal and local law enforcement, Deputy Escalante’s murderer, Carlos “Stoney” Velasquez, was sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole after he pleaded guilty to first-degree murder in state court. Three other Avenues gang members were also convicted in relation to the Escalante murder, and two others are pending trial in state court.
Release No. 13-123
Frontman in Rock Band Sentenced to 7 Years in Federal Prison After Pleading Guilty in Multi-Million Dollar Loan Fraud CaseRead the Press Release
SANTA ANA, California – The singer in a Los Angeles-based rock band called Lights Over Paris was sentenced today to seven years in federal prison for submitting false documents to banks to fraudulently obtain millions of dollars in loans, money that he used to fund his musical project and his lavish lifestyle.
Robert Brandon Mawhinney, 30, of Anaheim, was sentenced earlier today by United States District Judge Cormac J. Carney.
Mawhinney pleaded guilty on April 22 to four counts of making false statements to federally insured banks and one count of money laundering. The very next day, according to prosecutors, Mawhinney made additional false statements to another financial institution in an attempt to obtain more credit – conduct that resulted in Judge Carney revoking his bond and remanding him into custody.
“For approximately three and a half years [Mawhinney] obtained and assisted others to obtain substantial loans from multiple banks through fraud,” prosecutors wrote in a sentencing memorandum filed in court. “In order to obtain and maintain the loans, [the] defendant made myriad false statements to the victim banks and presented numerous false documents, including fabricated financial statements and tax returns bearing the forged signatures of identity-theft victims. Even [the] defendant’s family members’ documents weren’t safe; for instance, [Mawhinney] used his grandfather’s Schwab account statements to create some of the fraudulent statements showing inflated balances that he gave to the victim banks.”
Mawhinney, who used the stage name Robb “TaLLLLL” University, obtained more than $11 million in credit after applying for loans by submitting phony brokerage statements that falsely showed that he had almost $8 million in assets. The phony statements were altered versions of real statements from brokerage accounts that actually contained less than $10,000. Mawhinney told bank officials that he needed the money to fund his music business and to purchase recording equipment. According to investigators, Mawhinney used the money from the loans to pay for travel, entertainment and a luxury tour bus that cost well over $750,000. The victim banks were Comerica, JP Morgan Chase, Zions Bank and Bank of America.
Mawhinney “used the millions of dollars that he fraudulently obtained for the selfish purpose of funding his fantasy of being a rock star,” according to the government’s sentencing memo. Judge Carney said today that Mawhinney’s motives for the crimes were “ego and greed.”
In a related case, Mawhinney helped two associates fraudulently obtain more than $1.7 in loans for their music business.
When Mawhinney defaulted on his loans, the victim banks sustained actual losses of over $8.4 million. When his associates defaulted on their loans, lending institutions suffered losses of approximately $1.75 million.
This case was investigated by the Federal Bureau of Investigation and IRS - Criminal Investigation.
Release No. 13-124
Two Compton Men Plead Guilty to Federal Hate Crime Charges Resulting from New Year’s Eve Attack on African-American YouthsRead the Press Release
LOS ANGELES – Two Latino men associated with a Compton street gang pleaded guilty this morning to federal hate crime charges stemming from a racially motivated attack on African-American juveniles on New Year’s Eve.
Jeffrey Aguilar, who is also known as “Terco,” 20, and Efren Marquez Jr., who is also known as “Stretch” and “Junior,” 22, each pleaded guilty to violating the Matthew Shepard-James Byrd Hate Crime Prevention Act.
Appearing before United States District Judge Terry J. Hatter Jr., Aguilar admitted that on December 31, 2012, he and another individual physically attacked a 17-year-old African-American, who was walking down a street in the City of Compton. Aguilar chased down and struck the victim in the head with a metal pipe. During the incident, Marquez threatened to shoot another African-American juvenile who was present. Both Aguilar and Marquez admitted that the attack on the 17-year-old victim was substantially motivated by his race and color.
“The perpetrators of hate crimes hurt not only the individuals who are attacked, but also society as a whole,” said United States Attorney André Birotte Jr. “For this reason, we are dedicated to working with our law enforcement partners to ensure that justice is brought to those who chose to commit such heinous crimes.”
Roy L. Austin, Jr., Deputy Assistant Attorney General for the Civil Rights Division of the Department of Justice, commented: “These juvenile victims were threatened and assaulted because of their race. Such intimidation and violence has no place in our society. The Justice Department will continue to vigorously prosecute those who commit such acts of hate.”
Aguilar and Marquez are scheduled to be sentenced by Judge Hatter on January 6. At sentencing each defendant will face a statutory maximum penalty of 10 years in federal prison.
“Finding justice for victims of civil rights violations is among the most important responsibilities of FBI agents,” said Bill Lewis, Assistant Director for the FBI’s Los Angeles Field Office. “The success of this case is due to the shared goals and long-term cooperation between the Los Angeles Sheriff's Department and the FBI, and prosecutors at the Department of Justice and the United States Attorney’s Office in Los Angeles.”
Sheriff Lee Baca commented: “Hate crimes affect not only the victims, they also destroy our society’s democratic principles. Law enforcement is dedicated to protecting the civil rights of all members of our community. The success of this joint investigation sends a message that racially motivated crimes will not be tolerated.”
This case is the result of an investigation conducted by the Federal Bureau of Investigation and the Los Angeles County Sheriff's Department.
Release No. 13-121
O.C. Doctor Who Illegally Prescribed Addictive Pain Medications, Often Meeting with Patients at Starbucks, Gets 11¼-Year SentenceRead the Press Release
SANTA ANA, California – An Orange County physician who admitted that he illegally prescribed dangerous, addictive painkillers to “patients” he barely examined during meetings that were often held at Starbucks stores was sentenced late today to over 11 years in federal prison.
Alvin Mingczech Yee, 44, of Mission Viejo, was sentenced this afternoon to 135 months in prison by United States District Judge Andrew J. Guilford.
Yee pleaded guilty in April to seven counts of illegal distribution of a controlled substance by a practitioner. Yee specifically admitted that he prescribed drugs, such as oxycodone and alprazolam, “while intentionally acting outside the usual course of professional practice and without a legitimate medical purpose.”
According to court documents previously filed in this case, Yee met with numerous “patients,” including three undercover operatives, during evening meetings at Starbucks across Orange County, where he wrote prescriptions for drugs best known by brand names such as OxyContin, Vicodin and Xanax.
The investigation of Yee was conducted by the Drug Enforcement Administration, which received the assistance of the Orange Police Department, the Huntington Beach Police Department and the California Medical Board.
Release No. 13-122
Burbank-based Diagnostic Labs Agrees to Pay $17.5 Million to Resolve Illegal Kickback AllegationsRead the Press Release
LOS ANGELES – Kan-Di-Ki, LLC, doing business as Diagnostic Laboratories and Radiology (Diagnostic Labs), has agreed to pay $17.5 million to resolve allegations that it submitted false claims to Medicare and Medi-Cal (the State of California’s Medicaid program) that were tainted by a kickback scheme.
Diagnostic Labs, which is headquartered in Burbank, provides lab and x-ray services to patients at skilled nursing facilities (SNFs) in Southern California. SNFs, commonly known as nursing homes, are a healthcare option for senior citizens who are in need of constant medical attention.
Diagnostic Labs allegedly charged SNFs below cost rates for Medicare Part A business, in exchange for the facilities’ provision of Medicare Part B and Medi-Cal business back to Diagnostic Labs. This scheme is alleged to have violated the federal Anti-Kickback Act (42 U.S.C. § 1320a-7b(b)(2)(A)) and the federal and state False Claims Acts.
“When medical facility owners illegally offer discounts to customers to generate business, it results in inflated claims to government health care programs and increases costs for all taxpayers,” said Glenn R. Ferry, Special Agent in Charge for the Los Angeles Region of the Department of Health and Human Services’ Office of Inspector General. “This $17.5 million settlement demonstrates OIG’s ongoing commitment to safeguarding federal health care programs and taxpayer dollars against all types of fraudulent activities.”
The United States will receive $12.95 million of the settlement amount, and California will receive $4.55 million.
This settlement resolves a lawsuit filed under the qui tam, or “whistleblower,” provisions of the federal and state False Claims Acts, which allow private citizens with knowledge of fraud to bring civil actions on behalf of the federal and state governments and share in any recovery. The case was filed in 2010 in federal court in Los Angeles by two former Diagnostic Labs employees, and is titled United States and State of California ex rel. Pasqua et al. v. Kan-Di-Ki, LLC, Civil Action No. CV10-0965 JST (RZx) (C.D. Cal.). The two men who filed the lawsuit, Jon Pasqua and Jeff Hauser, will collectively receive $3,755,500 as their share of the federal recovery. Their share of the state recovery has not yet been determined.
The United States Attorney’s Office for the Central District of California, the Justice Department’s Civil Division, and the California Attorney General’s Office handled the civil settlement. This matter was investigated by the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Office of Inspector General.
Release No. 13-120
Second Highest Chiropractic Medicare Biller in California Biller Pleads Guilty to Health Care FraudRead the Press Release
LOS ANGELES – A San Fernando Valley chiropractor, who was the second highest Medicare biller in California for chiropractic services, pled guilty yesterday to healthcare fraud in violation of 18 U.S.C. § 1347.
Between 2005 and 2012, Houshang Pavehzadeh aka “Danny Paveh” (41), owner of Sylmar Physician Medical Group, Inc. – a storefront chiropractic clinic located in a strip mall – defrauded Medicare by billing for patients he never treated.
The eleven count indictment alleges that Pavehzadeh submitted over $1.7 million in false and fraudulent claims to Medicare and was paid a little over $1 million on these claims. As part of his guilty plea, Pavehzadeh admitted that, in an effort to conceal his fraud from Medicare auditors, he staged an early-morning car jacking outside his office and falsely reported to the Los Angeles Police Department that his patient files had been stolen.
“Those persons who seek to bilk the Medicare Program impact both our health care delivery system and the American consumer,” said United States Attorney André Birotte Jr. “Here, the defendant not only tried to bilk the system to the tune of more than $1.7 million, he also had the audacity to try and conceal his criminal activity by filing a bogus police report with the LAPD.”
“Health care fraud in and of itself is a serious offense. Not content to stop there, however, Mr. Pavehzadeh sought to conceal that crime by committing yet another -- filing a false police report,” said Glenn R. Ferry, Special Agent in Charge for the Los Angeles Region of the Office of Inspector General for the Department of Health of Human Services. “Those intent on breaking these laws should know that through the work of our special agents and auditors, OIG remains committed to seeking justice.”
Pavehzadeh faces a maximum sentence of ten years imprisonment, a fine of $250,000 and three years of supervised release. United States District Judge Manuel L. Real is scheduled to sentence defendant on January 14, 2014.
Release No. 13-119
Operation ‘Smokin’ Aces’ Targets Mexican Mafia Operations in Orange CountyRead the Press Release
Federal and State Grand Juries Indict 129 Defendants who Allegedly Assisted the Prison Gang or Were Involved in the Business of Numerous O.C. Street Gangs
SANTA ANA, California – Hundreds of law enforcement officials this morning fanned out across Southern California to conclude Operation “Smokin’ Aces,” an investigation conducted by the Santa Ana Gang Task Force that targeted the Orange County wing of the Mexican Mafia, which allegedly exercises control over Latino street gangs and is a powerful force in the local jail system.
A total of 129 defendants have been named in indictments issued by county and federal grand juries. Each of the defendants is linked to an Orange County street gang that claims allegiance to the Mexican Mafia, which is also called the Eme. Some of the federal defendants also are associates of the prison gang who allegedly worked directly with one of the two Mexican Mafia members who oversee the Orange County wing of the criminal enterprise.
During the course of the investigation, task force members made undercover purchases of 67 weapons (38 handguns and 29 rifles). They also seized 22 pounds of methamphetamine, 1.5 pounds of heroin and three pounds of cocaine.
Over the past three months, a federal grand jury in Orange County has returned 26 indictments that charge a total of 86 defendants. The indictments allege a wide range of criminal conduct, including murder and assault, extortion and “tax” collection, and the street-level distribution of narcotics.
As part of Smokin’ Aces, the Orange County District Attorney has also obtained indictments that charge a total of 43 defendants.
At the center of Smokin’ Aces is a federal racketeering indictment that focuses on the operations of the Mexican Mafia in Orange County, a criminal organization that for many years has been headed by Peter Ojeda, who allegedly ordered murders and assaults on behalf of the Mexican Mafia. (Ojeda is not formally charged in the indictment unsealed today, but he is currently pending trial in another racketeering case that was filed in 2011 in relation to Operation “Black Flag.”)
The racketeering indictment alleges a conspiracy to violate RICO, the federal Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations Act. The RICO indictment unsealed today charges 26 defendants associated with the Orange County branch of the Mexican Mafia, including those who implemented orders given by Eme leaders, gang members who collected and delivered “tax payments,” and women associated with the organization who serve the “crucial” function of moving messages from incarcerated Mexican Mafia operatives to their minions on the streets.
The Mexican Mafia is a powerful and violent prison gang that controls drug distribution and other illegal activities within the California penal system and on the streets of Southern California by organizing Latino street gang members for the purpose of establishing a larger network for the Mexican Mafia’s illegal activities. If a street gang does not comply with the demands of the Mexican Mafia, the prison gang will order the assault or murder the offending gang’s members, whether they are in custody or on the streets.
The majority of the federal indictments target gang members who allegedly trafficked in significant quantities of narcotics and firearms. Two of the indictments outline large drug trafficking conspiracies, one of which focuses on the Santa Ana-based Delhi gang. The gang members and their associates were paying “taxes” or “rent” to the Mexican Mafia, and this revenue stream fortified the control the Mexican Mafia has over members of gangs, whether they are on the street or in custody.
The first large drug distribution indictment charges 15 people and outlines the activities of an organization allegedly run by George “Monk” Martinez and John Terrones, who are alleged leaders of the Santa Ana-based Delhi gang and who are also named in the RICO indictment. The narcotics indictment alleges a conspiracy to distribute methamphetamine and heroin.
The second narcotics trafficking indictment charges a dozen individuals with participating in a methamphetamine distribution organization headed by Mario Franco, a member of a Santa Ana-based gang who also is named in the RICO indictment.
Operation Smoking Aces is the latest action by the Santa Ana Gang Task Force to target the Mexican Mafia and its control over Latino street gangs in Orange County. In July 2011, authorities announced Operation “Black Flag,” which led to charges against 99 defendants, including Peter Ojeda (see: http://www.fbi.gov/losangeles/press-releases/2011/ninety-nine-members-and-associates-of-mexican-mafia-affiliated-gangs-charged-in-operation-black-flag).
Smokin’ Aces was an investigation conducted by the Santa Ana Gang Task Force, which is comprised of agents and officers with the Federal Bureau of Investigation; the Santa Ana Police Department; the Orange County Sheriff’s Department; the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco and Firearms and Explosives; and the California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation – Special Service Unit. Special Agents with IRS – Criminal Investigation also participated in Operation Smoking Aces.
Multiple agencies assisted during today’s operation, including personnel with the United States Marshals Service; the Anaheim Police Department; the Newport Beach Police Department; the Fountain Valley Police Department; the Huntington Beach Police Department; the Brea Police Department; the Irvine Police Department; the Buena Park Police Department; and the Garden Grove Police Department.
Release No. 13-118
Attorney Who Twice Helped Obstruct Investigations into $22 Million Ponzi Scheme Sentenced to Seven Years in Federal PrisonRead the Press Release
LOS ANGELES – A Santa Monica lawyer who was a partner at the Nixon Peabody law firm when he helped obstruct two separate investigations into an investment scheme that ultimately took $22 million from victims was sentenced this morning to 84 months in federal prison.
Attorney David Tamman, 46, was sentenced by United States District Judge Phillip S. Gutierrez, who also ordered the defendant to pay a $2,500 fine.
At today’s hearing, Judge Gutierrez said that, apart from the magnitude of the fraud Tamman helped cover up, the substantial sentence was warranted by the fact that the defendant lied to the Securities and Exchange Commission, and then compounded the matter by lying during his trial in 2012. Judge Gutierrez further indicated Tamman’s conduct was particularly troubling because he is a lawyer.
Following a bench trial last year, Tamman was found guilty of 10 counts that included obstruction of justice, altering records in a federal investigation, and being an accessory after the fact to the fraud scheme. The evidence presented at the trial showed that Tamman conspired with John Farahi, who operated the Ponzi scheme, to obstruct an SEC investigation into the fraud scheme. Tamman, who was suspended from practicing law earlier this year by the California State Bar, served as outside counsel for Farahi’s investment company, Newpoint Investment Services.
“Despite being a highly educated lawyer, defendant David Tamman has displayed a remarkable disrespect for the law and the legal system over the course of almost a decade,” prosecutors wrote in a sentencing brief that stated Tamman altered documents that caused the National Association of Securities Dealers (which is now known as FINRA) to close an investigation in 2004, thereby enabling Farahi to continue bilking victims for another five years.
Prosecutors said that in 2009, in response to an investigation being conducted by the Securities and Exchange Commission, Tamman and Farahi altered and created securities offering documents and promissory notes, as well as lied to the SEC and Tamman’s colleagues.
“But even after Farahi’s crimes were discovered, [Tamman] still did not stop obstructing justice,” prosecutors wrote in their sentencing memo. “In 2011, [Tamman] began obstructing the grand jury’s investigation of his own crimes,” which included lying to federal investigators, giving “false testimony” at his trial last November, and lying to a Probation Officer who was preparing a pre-sentence report after he was found guilty.
Farahi, a former investment fund manager and radio personality, was sentenced in March to 10 years in federal prison for running the $24+ million scheme (see http://www.justice.gov/usao/cac/Pressroom/2013/036.html). Farahi, who operated the Beverly Hills-based New Point Financial Services, Inc. and had a regular radio show on KIRN-AM, admitted bilking investors by falsely promising to purchase corporate bonds backed by the Troubled Asset Relief Program (TARP).
The case against Farahi and Tamman is the result of an investigation by the Office of the Special Inspector General for the Troubled Asset Relief Program (SIGTARP) and the Federal Bureau of Investigation. The SEC provided substantial assistance during the investigation.
“Today justice was served for Tamman’s attempted massive cover-up of John Farahi’s multi-million dollar Ponzi scheme in which Farahi lied to investors and claimed that he was investing in safe, TARP-backed corporate bonds,’ said Christy Romero, Special Inspector General for TARP (SIGTARP). “Contrary to his claims, Farahi used investors’ funds to bankroll his lavish lifestyle and high-risk trading which resulted in heavy losses for investors and TARP banks. As Farahi’s attorney, Tamman was Farahi’s enabler, falsifying and backdating business documents to hide the fraud, and as a result, Tamman will spend the next seven years in federal prison. If you exploit TARP or otherwise help others defraud taxpayers’ TARP investments, you’ll be held accountable by SIGTARP and our law enforcement partners and be forced to answer for your transgressions.”
The SEC filed a federal civil complaint alleging violations of the federal securities laws against Farahi and others in January 2010. The lawsuit alleged that Farahi and others conducted an unregistered offering fraud aimed at Iranian-Americans in the Los Angeles area (see: http://www.sec.gov/news/press/2010/2010-3.htm). The SEC subsequently obtained a permanent injunction, as well as orders freezing Farahi’s and New Point’s assets and appointing a receiver over New Point Financial Services.
Release No. 13-117
Owner of Home Health Agency That Defrauded Medicare Ordered to Pay $14.9 Million – Three Times the Losses Caused by SchemeRead the Press Release
LOS ANGELES – A federal judge has ordered the owner of a home health agency that operated in the Westlake District of Los Angeles to pay nearly $15 million – or approximately three times the losses suffered by Medicare as a result of the company’s illegal practices.
United States District Judge Stephen V. Wilson previously issued a $14,902,832 default judgment against Hee Jung Mun, the former owner and operator of GreatCare Home Health Agency, who was commonly known as Angela Mun. The judgment resolves a “whistleblower” lawsuit filed by GreatCare’s receptionist.
The judgment against Mun and the conclusion of the whistleblower lawsuit was announced today when the U.S. Marshals service transferred to the United States Treasury $1,297,958 that was seized in March 2011 when federal agents executed a search warrant at GreatCare and executed seizure warrants on GreatCare’s and Mun’s bank accounts.
GreatCare paid kickbacks to physicians and others to induce them to refer patients to GreatCare in a $5 million Medicare fraud scheme.
In January 2012, Mun pleaded guilty to healthcare fraud charges for her central role in a scheme that paid kickbacks to physicians and marketers who referred patients to GreatCare (see: http://www.justice.gov/archive/usao/cac/Pressroom/2012/008.html). As part of the scheme, Medicare beneficiaries were also paid to sign up for GreatCare’s service, even though many of them were not eligible for home health services. GreatCare billed Medicare for services that were not rendered, were unnecessary, and/or were performed by unlicensed personnel. Mun is currently scheduled to be sentenced in February.
In June, one of the physicians who received kickbacks for referring patients to GreatCare and signed false certificates of medical necessity – Dr. Dong Shin – agreed to pay the United States $217,810 to resolve his civil liability for his role in the scheme. The settlement amount was based upon Dr. Shin’s assessed ability to pay. Shin has paid $150,000 and has agreed to make monthly payments until the balance is paid off.
Also in June, Seonweon Kim, a physical therapist at GreatCare, agreed to pay the United States $205,000 to resolve his civil liability for his participation in the scheme. Kim pleaded guilty last year to healthcare fraud and admitted that he created false physical therapy notes that falsely indicated he had provided various services to patients. Kim is also scheduled to be sentenced early next year. Kim has already paid $85,000 of the settlement amount; the remainder will be paid in monthly installments.
Another referring physician, Dr. Whan Sil Kim, pleaded guilty to receiving kickbacks and was sentenced last year to one year and one day in prison. In March, the Court entered a consent judgment against Dr. Kim pursuant to which she agreed to pay the United States $1,088,799 to resolve her liability in the civil action.
The judgment against Mun – which was filed by Judge Wilson on July 23 – and the settlements resolve the civil lawsuit United States ex rel. Kim v. GreatCare Home Health Agency, et al., a “whistleblower” lawsuit that alleged GreatCare billed Medicare for thousands of home health visits that were not rendered and/or were medically unnecessary. The lawsuit further alleged that GreatCare executed the scheme by recruiting Medicare beneficiaries and paying kickbacks to the beneficiaries and to doctors to induce referrals for home health services.
The Medicare fraud scheme came to light in March 2010 when GreatCare’s then-receptionist, Misha Kim, filed the qui tam lawsuit under the federal False Claims Act. United States District Judge Stephen V. Wilson unsealed the whistleblower lawsuit in October 2011. The United States did not intervene in the lawsuit, but actively participated in settlement negotiations and coordinated extensively with Relator’s counsel in bringing this case to completion.
The civil case was investigated by the Federal Bureau of Investigation and the Office of Inspector General of the U.S. Department of Health & Human Services.
Release No. 13-116
Desert Hot Springs Man Who Allegedly Escaped from Custody Faces New Charges Related to Pipe Bombs Found in Coachella ValleyRead the Press Release
Grand Jury Indicts Fugitive for Possessing 6 Pipe Bombs Found in Palm Springs
RIVERSIDE, California – Federal authorities are seeking the public’s help in apprehending a man who was indicted this week on federal charges of illegally possessing pipe bombs that were strewn about residential neighborhoods in Palm Springs last year.
Edward Allen Costa, 48, was indicted yesterday on six counts of possessing unregistered destructive devices (pipe bombs) and one count of escape from custody. Costa, who pleaded guilty last year to being a felon in possession of a firearm, allegedly walked away from a “halfway house” in Rubidoux last month.
The indictment alleges that Costa illegally possessed six pipes bombs that were left in various locations in Palm Springs from May 8 through May 12 last year. Costa was initially charged in relation to the pipe bombs in a criminal complaint filed in June 2012, but those charges were dismissed to allow additional investigation. When that complaint was dismissed, Costa was charged in another case being a convicted felon in possession of a .357-magnum revolver, as well as 106 rounds of ammunition.
Costa pleaded guilty late last year to the felon-in-possession charge, and he was sentenced in January by United States District Judge Virginia A. Phillips to one year and one day in federal prison. By August, the Bureau of Prisons had assigned Costa to a residential re-entry center in Rubidoux. According to court documents, Costa signed out of the facility in order to go to a state-run employment office, but he never returned. Costa was initially charged with escape in a criminal complaint filed in federal court on August 16.
Special agents with the Federal Bureau of Investigation and the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives had continued to investigate the case involving the pipe bombs. That investigation concluded yesterday when a federal grand jury in Riverside returned the seven-count indictment against Costa.
An indictment contains allegations that a defendant has committed a crime. Every defendant is presumed to be innocent until and unless proven guilty in court.
The charge of possession of an unregistered destructed device carries a statutory maximum penalty of 10 years in federal prison. The escape charge carries a statutory maximum penalty of five years in prison.
Costa is currently a fugitive being sought by federal authorities. Anyone with information about his whereabouts is encouraged to contact the FBI at this 24-hour number: 888-CANT HIDE (888-226-8443)
The case against Costa was investigated by the FBI and the ATF, which received substantial assistance from the Palm Springs Police Department and the Riverside County Sheriff’s Department. Also, the United States Marshals Service has provided substantial assistance in the effort to locate and arrest Costa.
Release No. 13-115
Eight Defendants Plead Guilty in Armenian Power RICO CaseRead the Press Release
LOS ANGELES – Four members and associates of the Armenian Power gang, as well as four others, pleaded guilty late Monday to charges related to the activities of the Armenian Power criminal enterprise, including racketeering conspiracy, bank fraud, aggravated identity theft, drug-trafficking and illegal possession of firearms.
The eight who pleaded guilty yesterday are among 70 people who were charged two years ago in a 140-count indictment that outlined the criminal activities of the Armenian Power gang. The indictment accused 29 defendants, including four of those who pleaded guilty yesterday, of participation in the Armenian Power racketeering conspiracy. The RICO count in the indictment alleges a host of illegal activities, including sophisticated fraud schemes involving identity theft, bank fraud, credit card skimming, counterfeit checks and money laundering. The indictment also alleged a variety of violent crimes, such as extortion, kidnapping and firearms offenses.
The racketeering indictment alleges a bank fraud and identity theft scheme that victimized hundreds of customers of 99 Cents Only Stores across Southern California. Through the scheme, defendants caused more than $2 million in losses when they secretly installed sophisticated “skimming” devices to steal customer debit card account information at cash registers, and then used the skimmed information to create counterfeit debit cards that were used to steal money from victims’ bank accounts.
The eight defendants who pleaded guilty yesterday before United States District Judge Dean D. Pregerson are: Karo Yerkanyan, also known as “Guilty,” 32, of Tujunga, who pleaded guilty to racketeering conspiracy, bank fraud, aggravated identity theft, conspiracy to possess with the intent to distribute marijuana, and felon in possession of a firearm;
Arman Tangabekyan, aka “Spito and “Thick Neck,” 34, of Encino, who pleaded guilty to racketeering conspiracy, bank fraud and aggravated identity theft;
Artur Pembejian, aka “Cham,” 36, of Burbank, who pleaded guilty to racketeering conspiracy;
Raymond Tarverdyan, aka “Rye,” 35, of Montrose, who pleaded guilty to racketeering conspiracy and bank fraud;
Simon Antonyan, aka “Simo,” 38, of Hollywood, who pleaded guilty to aggravated identity theft;
Khachatur Arakelyan, aka “Khecho,” 39, of Glendale, who pleaded guilty to aggravated identity theft;
Vartenie Ananian, 29, of Tujunga, who pleaded guilty to bank fraud; and
Adam Davoodian, 32, of Glendale, who pleaded guilty to conspiracy to possess with intent to distribute marijuana.
The eight defendants who pleaded guilty yesterday played various roles in the activities of the Armenian Power gang, including participating in bank fraud, drug distribution, access device fraud, identity theft and illegal firearm possession.
Yerkanyan, a member of the Armenian Power conspiracy, participated in a bank fraud scheme that obtained the personal identifying information and account information of victims. He and his co-conspirators used the information to open fraudulent bank accounts, loans and lines of credit at HSBC Bank and Bank of America without the knowledge of the victims. Yerkanyan also participated, along with Davoodian, in a scheme to steal approximately 207 pounds of marijuana, worth approximately $450,000, from another drug distributor.
Tangabekyan, another member of the Armenian Power conspiracy, participated in a bank fraud scheme by obtaining personal information and account information for victims and then obtaining or transferring over $475,000 in funds.
Pembejian, a member of the Armenian Power conspiracy, abetted the illegal possession of a firearm by a leader of the Armenian Power gang, Mher Darbinyan.
Tarverdyan, an Armenian Power member – along with Antonyan, Arakelyan and Ananian – participated in the scheme to secretly install the skimming devices at the 99 Cents Only Stores.
According to court documents, the Armenian Power street gang formed in the East Hollywood district of Los Angeles in the 1980s. The gang’s membership consisted primarily of individuals of Armenian descent, as well as of other countries within the former Soviet bloc. The Armenian Power has been designated under California state law as a criminal street gang and is believed to have over 250 documented members, as well as hundreds of associates. According to court documents, Armenian Power members and associates regularly carry out violent criminal acts, including murders, attempted murders, kidnappings, robberies, extortions, and witness intimidation in order to enrich its members and associates and preserve and enhance the power of the criminal enterprise.
The defendants who pleaded guilty this week are scheduled to be sentenced by Judge Pregerson beginning on November 25. At sentencing, Yerkanyan faces a maximum penalty of 102 years in prison. Tangabekyan faces a maximum penalty of 52 years in prison. Tarverdyan faces a maximum penalty of 50 years in prison. Ananian faces a maximum penalty of 30 years in prison. Pembejian and Davoodian each face a maximum penalty of 20 years in prison. And Antonyan and Arakelyan each face a maximum penalty of two years in prison.
Fifty-one other defendants have previously pleaded guilty in the racketeering case.
This case is being prosecuted by the United States Attorney’s Office in Los Angeles and the Department of Justice’s Organized Crime and Gang Section.
The case was investigated by the Eurasian Organized Crime Task Force, which is comprised of the Federal Bureau of Investigation, the United States Secret Service, the Los Angeles Police Department, the Glendale Police Department, the Burbank Police Department, the Internal Revenue Service - Criminal Investigation, and U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement’s Homeland Security Investigations.
In addition to the racketeering indictment targeting Armenian Power, federal authorities in 2011 obtained a second indictment that was filed in Orange County. The case charged 22 defendants (two of whom were also charged in the racketeering indictment). Similar to some of the schemes alleged in the racketeering indictment, the Orange County case alleges that AP members, working in conjunction with members of African-American street gangs, engaged in a bank fraud scheme that targeted elderly victims and caused losses of at least $10 million. All of the defendants charged in that case have been convicted, with two of them already receiving sentences of 25 years in federal prison.
Release No. 13-114
Oxnard Man Who Kidnapped Former Girlfriend and Threatened to Kill Her in Mexico Is Sentenced to over 24 Years in Federal PrisonRead the Press Release
LOS ANGELES – A Ventura County man who kidnapped his former girlfriend and drove her to Mexico while threatening to kill her and dump her body was sentenced this morning to 293 months in federal prison.
Rudy Soto, 26, of Oxnard, was sentenced by United States District Judge Otis D.
Wright II.Soto was convicted following a week-long jury trial in July 2012 of conspiring to kidnap and kidnapping. The evidence at trial showed that after a heated exchange between Soto and the victim on September 14, 2010, Soto traveled from Oxnard to the victim’s residence near downtown Los Angeles. When the victim refused to accompany him, Soto carried and dragged the victim, who was screaming and kicking him, to a waiting truck that was being driven by co-defendant Erin Nicole Fisher, 22. Soto, using the weight of his body, pinned the victim to the front passenger seat while Fisher drove the vehicle to Mexico.
During this drive, Soto told the victim he was taking her to Mexico, where she was going to die. Soto also contacted the victim’s family and advised her brother-in-law that he was taking the victim to Tijuana and would dump her there. When the victim tried to fight or escape, Soto held a knife to her throat and threatened to kill her.
Eventually, the victim accepted that she was going to be killed, and gave up trying to fight Soto and escape. During her testimony, she told the jury: “I was tired, and I just resigned myself. And I said if he is going to kill me, let him kill me.”At the Otay Mesa checkpoint at the United States-Mexico border, Mexican authorities stopped the pickup truck, which prompted the victim to scream for help. After telling Mexican authorities about her plight and being threatened with a knife, Mexican authorities detained Soto, Fisher and the victim. After the victim was examined by a
Mexican army physician, she was released. Agents with United States Customs and
Border Protection helped return her to the United States.“To carry out his plan, [Spoto] physically restrained her, struck her, terrorized her, and threatened to kill her with a knife that he brandished,”prosecutors wrote in a sentencing memo. “In addition, he psychologically tortured the victim, playing on her emotions and the nature of their tumultuous relationship.”
Fisher is being prosecuted separately and is participating in a court-ordered diversionary program.
This case was investigated by the Federal Bureau of Investigation, which received substantial assistance from the U.S. Department of Justice’s Office of
International Affairs, U.S. Customs and Border Protection, the Los Angeles Police
Department, the FBI’s Legal Attache in Mexico City, and officials with the Justice
Department and the State Department assigned to the United States Embassy in
Mexico.Mexican authorities provided considerable assistance during this investigation, including the Secretaría de Marina - Armada de México (the Mexican Navy); the
Secretaría de la Defensa Nacional (the Mexican Army); and the Procuraduría General de la República (the Mexican Attorney General).Release No. 13-112